How is A Streetcar Named Desire a tragedy?

1 Answer

akannan's profile pic

Ashley Kannan | Middle School Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

I think that Williams' work is a tragedy for a couple of reasons.  In my mind, the most overwhelming reason that the story is a tragedy is because there is not a happy ending for anyone.  There is little in way of unity and comedy for any of the characters.  Blanche is institutionalized, Stella recognizes that she might have made a mistake only to be smoothed over by Stanley, exposed to be a brute in the most savage of ways.  This is a setting whereby disunity and fragmentation results for everyone.  I would say that another way the play is a tragedy is that it reveals a challenging situation between cultures, different ways of life, where validation is not really present.  Blanche is living in a different world, and it is one that has passed her by in a brutally honest manner.  Yet, if Stanley represents the force of modernity, one cannot take solace in that because any setting where someone as harsh and as brutish as Stanley cannot represent a force of salvation.  In this light, the drama reflects another tragic condition.