How logical is the nymph's reply?

Asked on by lou941

1 Answer | Add Yours

Top Answer

epollock's profile pic

epollock | (Level 3) Valedictorian

Posted on

The nymph’s refutation may be schematized in a logical pattern: 1. If a, then b. 2. Not a. 3. Therefore, not b. The 1 is “if the world were young, etc., then I would live with you” (brought out in stanza 1). The 2 is all the negative detail in stanzas 2–5. The 3 is the final stanza, in which she draws the conclusion of the previous stanzas. The world is not eternally young and pleasant, and therefore she rejects the shepherd; in fact, however, even if the world were perfect, she does not concede to the shepherd that he would be her choice (“my mind might move,” line 24). This a very logical argument that can be understood in an elementary rhetorical class or on paper if one were to draw a simple flow chart.

We’ve answered 319,857 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question