Illustration of Pip visiting a graveyard

Great Expectations

by Charles Dickens
Start Free Trial

How does Pip's discussion with Jaggers disabuse him of the notion that Miss Havisham has been his patron?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In Chapter 39 Pip has the totally astonishing and traumatic meeting with his real benefactor Abel Magwitch, and in Chapter 40 Pip goes to Mr. Jaggers' office to confront him.

"I merely want, Mr. Jaggers," said I "to assure myself what I have been told, is true. I have no...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

In Chapter 39 Pip has the totally astonishing and traumatic meeting with his real benefactor Abel Magwitch, and in Chapter 40 Pip goes to Mr. Jaggers' office to confront him.

"I merely want, Mr. Jaggers," said I "to assure myself what I have been told, is true. I have no hope of its being untrue, but as least I may verify it."

Jaggers is characteristically cautious in his reply, but he acknowledges that he has been representing Magwitch in Pip's behalf for all these years and that Miss Havisham was not involved in providing any money for Pip's advancement in life. Jaggers pretends to believe that Magwitch is still living in New South Wales. He very obviously does not want to know anything about his client's possible return to England, although it is clear to the reader that he does know about it.

Pip will later go to confront Miss Havisham to express his indignation at the way she has led him to believe that she was his secret patron. She confirms his accusation but does not seem to care in the least about his injured feelings--or the feelings of any man.

Ironically, in making Pip a gentleman, Magwitch has also made it impossible for him to accept his fortune, and without the fortune which was part of his great expectations, Pip feels he cannot marry Estella. Dickens does not explain exactly why Pip, as a gentleman, cannot accept Magwitch's money, but it must have something to do with the fact that the money was earned by a convict transported to Australia and who is risking hanging by coming back to England in violation of his sentence.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I do not know which discussion between Pip and Jaggers you are talking about here so I do not know how Pip would have been disabused.

To me, Pip learns who his patron was in Chapter XXXIX.  In that chapter, the convict, Magwitch, comes to Pips apartments and has a chat with him.  He tells Pip that he has been Pip's benefactor.  Pip asks him if Miss Havisham had anything to do with it and Magwitch says she did not.

You can see from the following quote that Pip did not know who his patron was before this conversation:

"Well, you see it wos me, and single-handed. Never a soul in it but my own self and Mr. Jaggers."

"Was there no one else?" I asked.

"No," said he, with a glance of surprise: "who else should there be?

Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on