In "The Pit and the Pendulum" how does the narrator determine the size of his prison? What error does he make?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The prison where the narrator is placed is completely dark, leaving him unaware of the boundaries and dimensions of the cell. Initially, the narrator walks forward with his arms outstretched thinking about the numerous horror stories he has heard regarding the dungeons in Toledo. When the narrator touches a wall,...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

The prison where the narrator is placed is completely dark, leaving him unaware of the boundaries and dimensions of the cell. Initially, the narrator walks forward with his arms outstretched thinking about the numerous horror stories he has heard regarding the dungeons in Toledo. When the narrator touches a wall, he begins to follow it and realizes that he has no understanding of the dimensions of the prison because he may be walking in a circle. He then tears a long strand of cloth from his robe and places it at a right angle against the wall so that he will feel the cloth when he walks over it. While groping his way around the prison, the narrator becomes excessively fatigued and falls to the floor. When the narrator awakens, he continues walking around the prison until he reaches the cloth. The narrator travels one hundred paces and presumes that the size of the cell is about fifty yards in circuit.

He then attempts to walk directly across the cell and takes ten or twelve steps before tripping over his robe. When the narrator falls on his face, his chin touches the ground while the rest of his head hangs in mid-air. He then stretches his arms out and discovers that there is a massive pit in the center of the cell. When a prison door is opened, a flash of light illuminates the cell and the narrator witnesses the massive pit. Shortly after falling asleep, the narrator awakens and sees the actual size of his cell, which is merely twenty-five yards in dimension. He realizes that he made an error counting his steps the first time. He had initially counted fifty-two steps before he fell and was unaware that he was only a few yards from the strip of cloth, where he started his journey. When he continued his journey, he was simply walking over his initial steps and accidentally doubled the circuit, leaving him to believe that his cell was twice its actual size.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Because he is in total darkness, the narrator must use other means to determine the nature of his prison.  It must have been terrifying to not know where he was, or how big the prison was, or anything about it; such disorientation would be completely horrifying.  However, he gathers strength, and decides to explore.  He does so first of all through feel--he steps forward, arms outstretched, until he hits a wall.  He realizes that if he follows the wall, he could go in a complete circle and not realize where he had begun.  So, he tears part of the robe that he was put in, and makes a sort of rope that he puts on the ground; that way, he will step on it after he makes one round of the prison, and know that he has come full circle.  He walks around the edges, counting his footsteps, concluding "the dungeon to be fifty yards in circuit."  So, that is how he figures out the size of his prison.  However, the entire time that he did this, he was along the edges of the walls; this didn't factor in the great pit looming ominously at the center.  He starts to walk across the prison, and fortunately for him, trips on his robe before he gets to the pit.  He falls, and notices

"my chin rested upon the floor of the prison, but my lips and the upper portion of my head, although seemingly at a less elevation than the chin, touched nothing."

This is how he discovers the pit, and he was very lucky to not have plunged right in; tripping saved him from the mistake of confidently striding across a prison in the dark.  His tormentors, thwarted in their original plan to have him fall, then had to come up with a different plan of torture.

I hope that those thoughts helped; good luck!

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team