How does O. Henry’s use of irony create a humorous tone?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

When the narrator and Bill Driscoll select their kidnapping victim, Johnny, the son of prominent citizen Ebenezer Dorset, they anticipate some quick, easy money from their ransom demand of two thousand dollars. After spending some time with the boy, these criminals reduce the ransom to fifteen hundred dollars because they...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

When the narrator and Bill Driscoll select their kidnapping victim, Johnny, the son of prominent citizen Ebenezer Dorset, they anticipate some quick, easy money from their ransom demand of two thousand dollars. After spending some time with the boy, these criminals reduce the ransom to fifteen hundred dollars because they figure it isn't fair to ask for so much for a "forty-pound chunk of freckled wildcat." To reduce the ransom based on the boy's behavior is both ironic and humorous, as is the fact that Johnny is both enjoying his captivity and mistreating his kidnappers.

The main irony in the story is that, instead of receiving any ransom money at all, the narrator and Bill end up having to meet Ebenezer Driscoll's demand for $250 to take the boy back. Johnny Dorset is such a handful that his kidnappers eagerly take the counter-demand just to get the boy off their hands. It is ironic that two adult criminals are no match for a small boy, and both their desperation to be rid of him and his father's demand are quite humorous.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

My favorite use of irony in "The Ransom of Red Chief" is the verbal irony that happens at the end of Bill and Sam's letter to Ebenezer Dorset.  

These terms are final, and if you do not accede to them no further communication will be attempted.

Two Desperate Men.

Remember that Bill and Sam are two "hardened" criminals that have kidnapped a child.  They are dangerous men presumably because they are desperate enough to try anything . . . including kidnapping. At least that's the message that would be sent if the kidnappers were anybody other than Bill and Sam and the victim was anybody other than Johnny Dorset.  In this case, Bill and Sam are desperate to get rid of Johnny.  They are at their wits end.  They are scared of Johnny and desperate to escape his enthusiasm.  

The other irony that is humorous to me is situational irony.  I mentioned before that Bill and Sam are criminals that are willing to kidnap a young boy.  They should be cruel enough to control and scare little Johnny Dorset.  That's what readers would expect to happen; however, the absolute opposite is what happens. Bill and Sam actually cower from Johnny and have zero control over this kid.  Ironically enough, they don't get any ransom money.  In fact Bill and Sam end up paying Ebenzer to take his kid back.  So for all of their trouble, Bill and Sam actually lost money.  That story is hilarious, because everything that happens is ironic.  

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team