How does Hamlet's "To be, or not to be" speech help make Hamlet a three-dimensional, realistic character?

Hamlet's "To be, or not to be" speech helps to make Hamlet a more three-dimensional character both through the content of the speech itself and through the context in which it is given.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

When it comes to Hamlet's famous "To be, or not to be" speech in act 3, scene 1, I actually think there are two separate aspects through which this speech can be analyzed: there is the content of the speech itself, but there is also the larger context in which it is given.

This larger context is especially important when you consider that there is an ambiguity within the play as to whether Hamlet is actually feigning insanity or whether he actually is mad (this ambiguity can allow different productions to advance a wide range of dramatic interpretations on this specific question).

In the speech, Hamlet contemplates of suicide. Here again, you might actually bring up a second, deeper layer of context, given that Hamlet's deeply melancholic mood had already been established from early in the play and his mental equilibrium has only been further thrown off balance by his encounter with the ghost and the revelations of his father's moment. Hamlet is in a state of psychological torment throughout the play, and this speech expresses this internal torment and indecision that grips him.

This sense of torment is reflected in his words about suicide. On the one hand, they express a weariness of life, but on the other hand, they also express a fear about the uncertainty of death and the unknown possibilities inherent in the afterlife. These words then express that same sense of uncertainty and indecision that plagues Hamlet throughout the play, while being expressed in a way that further gives evidence of the brooding, intelligent, and introspective personality of Hamlet himself. At the same time, the ambiguities within the scene lend further ambiguities to Hamlet's own mental state and personality, creating further realm of creative interpretation on the part of actors and productions.

Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on