What does John Grisham's The Appeal inform us about the politics of judicial elections?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Grisham's The Appeal offers a scary look at the current state of the American judicial system. The story follows a case through the Mississippi court system, which involves a chemical company who distributes cancer-causing pollutants. The case ultimately ends up in the Supreme Court of Mississippi where the justices are divided on the issue. Ultimately, the difference between the plaintiffs winning or losing against the chemical company will come down to the court's new justice.

What ensues is a harsh look at the political realities of judicial elections in the United States. The chemical company supports Ron Fisk who they groom to be sympathetic to their positions. The company hires a firm that specializes in rigging elections and they rely on the fact that most voters don't know anything about the justices on the ballot.

Grisham shows us in The Appeal that the American court system can, in many ways, be bought by large corporations. He hypothesizes that as long as private money is permitted to be a part of the judicial election process, our court system is compromised. This is important because if the United States' court system isn't a fair and neutral institution like we believed it to be, then we have to consider whether it can actually provide justice. The Appeal deals with many of the questions and problems associated with this issue.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

One moral lesson John Grisham clearly reveals in his novel The Appeal concerns the potential corruption of judicial elections. Some states, though not all, elect judges into office rather than having them appointed. Grisham is pointing out the potential for corruption in a system that elects judges.

For those states that elect judges, two different methods can be used. Some states hold partisan elections in which only a chosen electorate can vote. Judges in partisan elections are chosen based on party rather than the person. Other states, like Mississippi, hold non-partisan elections in which candidates' names are placed on a ballot and voted on, but their party affiliation is not listed on the ballot. Grisham shows that, when individuals are voted on, big money and private interests can play a large role in corrupting elections.  

In his novel, Krane Chemicals has just been found guilty in a trial of emptying carcinogenic toxic wastes into Bowmore, Mississippi, contaminating the town's water. The carcinogens have made Bowmore's cancer rate 15 times greater than the nation's average cancer rate, and Krane Chemicals has just been ordered by the court to pay $41 million in damages to Jeannette Baker for the deaths of both her husband and son. However, Krane Chemicals is intent on overturning the court's decision through appealing to the Mississippi Supreme Court, which will soon be electing new judges.

The owner of Krane Chemicals, Carl Trudea, knows he may successively get the case appealed if he can manipulate the elections; he, therefore, hires a firm by the name of Troy-Hogan to do just that. The owner of Troy-Hogan, Rinehart, knows they can win the appeal if they swap the more liberal Justice Sheila McCarthy for the more conservative Christian candidate Ron Fisk. Both the firm and Krane Chemicals begin illegally dumping money into Fisk's campaign to make McCarthy look morally untrustworthy and Fisk trustworthy, and the scheme works. Though Fisk begins having moral objections to ruling in favor of the appeal, the novel ends with Fisk taking the side of Krane Chemicals simply because of all the money the company invested in Fisk's campaign, showing us just how much big money can corrupt a judicial election, as well as any election.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team

We’ll help your grades soar

Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now.

  • 30,000+ book summaries
  • 20% study tools discount
  • Ad-free content
  • PDF downloads
  • 300,000+ answers
  • 5-star customer support
Start your 48-Hour Free Trial