What Does The Title "two Kinds" Mean? What Are There Two Kinds Of? What Do Those Two Kinds Have To Do With The Piano Pieces "pleading Child" And "perfectly Contented"?

How do “Pleading Child”and “Perfectly Contented” have a double meaning in the story? What does the last sentence of the story mean?

Asked on by blandine

2 Answers

teacherscribe's profile pic

teacherscribe | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Associate Educator

Posted on

Jing-Mei realizes, years later, that "Pleading Child" and "Perfectly Contented" are two halves of the same song.  As an impetuous and head-strong child, the narrator doesn't appreciate all that her mother does for her.  As an adult she realizes all that her mother tried to do for her - buying her a piano, arranging lessons, pushing and motivating her.  She just wanted Jing-Mei to have a better life than she did.   Because she was so young and stubborn, she never was able to value all that her mother sacrificed for her.  However, after her mother's death, she examines the song book and realizes that "Pleading Child," is only half of the song.  The other half is "Perfectly Contented."  This symbolically stands for our narrator.  She used to be a pleading child, who never appreciated what her mother was trying to do for her.  But now as an adult, she is - maybe not perfectly contented - but she is much more content than she was as a child.  Jing-Mei has developed her own talents and abilities, which was really what her mother wanted her to do all along.

charlie101's profile pic

charlie101 | Student, Grade 9 | (Level 1) eNoter

Posted on

pleding child is a that pleases her mother even if he/she dont like it to obtain her mother's love. Perfectly contented is the one who follows her own mind and rebels. Remenber that jing mei's mother was chinesse there was a clash of cultures because jing mei was american