Is Holden himself guilty of being a phony?I want more than 3 quotes to prove this...

Asked on by addyxu

1 Answer | Add Yours

mstultz72's profile pic

mstultz72 | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

Since the novel is satire, Salinger's focus is more on the society as phony rather than the individual.  Of course Holden is a phony, but it is only because he is a victim of the phony culture.

On the phony scale, though, Holden is pretty low: he is materialistic and obsessed with sex.  But, he's tame compared to Stradlater, for instance.  Here are the major phonies:

1. Glad-handing adults (headmaster)

2. Over-sexed teens (Stradlater)

3. Pretentious snobs (Luce)

4. Celebrity-obsessed girls (in Lavender room)

5. Materialistic artists (D.B.)

Now that he is given a choice as a young adult, Holden is deciding whether or not to drop out of the phony culture.  He doesn't know if he is courageous enough to live as a non-phony for the rest of his life.

Holden fears being a hypocrite, or a phony.  He wants to live a quiet life surrounded by books instead of people and money, but he's afraid that he'll be the "wrong kind of monk," a "stupid bastard."

Later, on his run-away journey in the city, Holden sees two nuns and their dilapidated suitcases.  The nuns also are symbols of holiness, and their suitcases are symbols of modesty, humility, and anti-materialism.  Holden likes the way they look and the way they "never [go] anywhere swanky for lunch."  As such, nuns are some of the few non-phonies in the entire novel.

All this is echoed near the end of the novel when Holden gets advice from Mr. Antolini, an Italian and--like Mercutio and the nuns--likely a Catholic.  He says Holden is “in for a terrible fall”:

"The mark of the immature man is that he wants to die nobly for a cause, while the mark of the mature man is that he wants to live humbly for one."

Was Mercutio a noble man?  Are the nuns noble?  Would Holden be noble if he becomes Catholic?  Or joins a monastery?  What is Holden's noble cause?

Holden could end up like Mercutio or the nuns.  He could die for a noble cause, like Mercutio and James Castle, both of whom committed suicide.  Or, he would live humbly for one, like the nuns.

We’ve answered 319,863 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question