Is Hester Prynne a saint or sinner in The Scarlet Letter?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Of course the answer to this question is "neither" if she must be only one or the other. In one way, Hester Prynne in Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter is a much less complicated character than her lover because her great sin is known to all and how she deals with it is overt; however, because of that public punishment, Hester does not have to deal with the effects of her sin on her soul in the same way that Arthur Dimmesdale must. 

If a sinner is defined simply as someone who has sinned, then Hester is, indeed, a sinner. If we think of a sinner as being someone who persists in committing the same sin--then I might make the case that Hester is a sinner. The truth is that Hester is really only sorry for getting caught, which she does because she is pregnant. Her sin was not getting pregnant, though; her sin was loving a man who was not her husband while she was married. Thus the scarlet "A" for adultery emblazoned on her breast. True repentance requires a turning away from the sin, and while Hester is not with Arthur physically, she has not stopped loving him. In fact, when she get the chance, she commits to leaving Salem with him. She makes no apology for loving him even though she knows it is a sin.

Her attitude about sin and repentance is clear from this statement she makes to Dimmesdale in the forest:

"You wrong yourself in this," said Hester gently. "You have deeply and sorely repented. Your sin is left behind you, in the days long past. Your present life is not less holy, in very truth, than it seems in people's eyes. Is there no reality in the penitence thus sealed and witnessed by good works?  And wherefore should it not bring you peace?" 

When repentance is defined this way, as doing good works to compensate for one's wrongs, perhaps Hester is no longer a sinner; however, it is a wretched faith which requires only doing good but not changing one's heart in order to achieve true repentance. 

In terms of being a saint, Hester could be considered one only in terms of her charitable acts in town. While these are saintly actions, they do not make Hester a saint and more than my making a basket on the basketball court makes me an NBA All-Star. We have to take her in totality, and Hester certainly exhibits some less-than-saintly behaviors at times. For example, she is afraid to pray because she is afraid her hatred for the cruel women in town will turn her prayers to curses. She also hates Roger Chillingworth for what he has done to Arthur, though of course Chillingworth forgave her of a great sin. These are not the thoughts and attitudes of a true saint.

In short, Hester is just a human being, struggling with sin and occasionally achieving saintliness. That is all of us, it seems to me; we do the lofty and right thing sometimes, but we certainly wallow is sin just as often. Hester is a strong woman to endure such public humiliation, to help even those who have scorned her, and to stand by Arthur despite everything; while these things do not make her a complete saint, they certainly keep her from being an abject sinner. 

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Is Hester Prynne a secular saint in The Scarlet Letter?

Since the word secular means not of the religious sect, the Reverend Dimmesdale cannot be considered as the possible saint.  And, since the physician, Roger Chillingworth is likened to the black man of the forest because of his look and behavior, it is unlikely that he is the secular saint, either.

Therefore, there is only one main character remaining:  Hester Prynne.  Is she a saint, though?  With her charitable works and more humble attitude, her fellow townspeople do come to view the scarlet letter on her breast as signifying "Angel" and "Able," rather than as adulterer. They may perceive her differently because after time her mark and burden have given her sympathies "so intimate with the sinful brotherhood of mankind" that there is a communion of this pain with others, although they not recognize this as such. In Chapter XIII, Hawthorne writes of Hester,

...a species of general regard had ultimately grown up in reference to Hester Prynne.  It is to the credit of human nature, that, except where its selfishness is brought into play, it loves more readily than it hates.  Hatred, by a gradual and quiet process, will even be transformed to love, unless the change be impeded by a continually new irritation of the original feeling of hostility.  In this matter of Hester Prynne, there was neither irritation nor irksomeness  She never battled with the public, but submitted, uncomplainingly, to its worst usage; she made no claim upon it, in requital for what she suffered, she did not weigh upon its sympathies.  Then, also, the blameless purity of her life during all these years in which she had been set apart to infamy, was reckoned in her favour.  With nothing now to lose, in the sight of could only be a genuine regard for virtue that had brought back the poor wanderer to its paths....she was quick to give of her little substance to every demand of poverty....In all seasons of calamity...she came as an inmate into the houshold...there glimmered the embroidered letter, with comfort in its unearthly ray....Hester's nature showed itself warm and rich....She was self-ordained a Sister of Mercy....

Virtuous, humble, charitable, lovin, and kind; Hester Prynne possesses the traits of a saint, indeed, but yet a saint who knows much of the world.  Truly, she can be considered a secular saint. 

Interestingly, however, although Hawthorne suggests that, contrary to Puritan teachings, there is redemption allowed to the sinner who admits to the sin and then commits good works, he makes the comment that the scarlet letter "has not done its office."  For, although Hester does good deeds and is much humbled, she does not regret her sin of passion as the Puritan leaders would have her do so; instead, she yet loves Dimmesdale as much as ever, if not more.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on