Is healthcare for all a good thing? 

Expert Answers
pohnpei397 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Most people would say that health care for all is a good thing.  However, people might not agree with the way in which health care is provided for everyone.  They might think that a given way of providing health care for everyone is bad for a country.  There are at least two aspects of how health care is provided that could cause people to think that a program that provides health care for all is not actually a good thing.

First of all, the health care program could work in a way that deprives people of their rights.  Many conservatives in the United States dislike “Obamacare” in part because it requires every individual in the US to either buy health insurance or pay a fine to the government.  Some people believe that this infringes on people’s rights to choose what to do with their own money.  In this view, health care for all is a good thing, but it is not appropriate to provide it by infringing on the rights of the people.

Second, we can argue that some ways of providing health care for all are less efficient than others and could actually harm both the health care industry and the economy as a whole.  This is another reason why many conservatives in the US dislike Obamacare.  They believe that Obamacare is bad because it is run too much by the government.  They would like health care for all to be provided by the market rather than by the government. They want a health care plan that has fewer government regulations and therefore allows market forces to play the main role.  They believe that such a program would provide consumers with the best choices at the best prices while still allowing the health care companies to make money.  In this view, health care for all is a good goal, but it should be provided in the most economically efficient way.

So, most people would say that it is good to provide health care to all people in a country. They might, however, argue about the best way to do it and they might reject a certain health care plan because they might think that its bad points outweigh its good points.