Law and Politics

Start Free Trial

What are some arguments for the idea that victimless crimes like gambling should be legalized?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The biggest way we can argue this point is by adopting a libertarian mindset, which is a mindset that the concept of freedom should allow an individual to do anything that they so choose, provided that that choice does not infringe upon another individual's prerogative to be free in the same way. The main argument in making gambling illegal is one similar to the argument against recreational drugs: that certain individuals are predisposed to addiction and will inevitably harm themselves in the act.

However, one could argue that in such a pursuit as gambling, if the individual chooses to engage in behavior that is potentially damaging to their well being, that is their choice alone, as the act would not be detrimental to another party.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

There are two main ways to make this argument.

First, we can argue this based on the idea that there is, as the term implies, no victim harmed by these crimes.  When people gamble of their own free will, they are not harmed by their choice any more than they might be harmed by other choices that they might make over the course of a day.  In other words, they may lose money gambling, but they are not hurting themselves more than if they (for example) spent the equivalent amount of money on a vacation or on attending expensive rock concerts.  If no one is hurt by the crime, it should not be a crime.

Second, we can argue this based on the idea that people should be as free as possible.  This is the idea that the government should not act as a “nanny state.”  If people want to hurt themselves, it should be their own choice to do so.  In a country like ours that is founded on the idea of liberty, we should not be restricting people’s liberty simply because we think what they are doing is bad for them.  When we do restrict liberty in this way, we are moving down the road to a situation in which the government has too much control over the things we do and the choices we make.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team