In Proof by David Auburn, has Catherine inherited her father's mathematical genius or his mental illness?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

It is a difficult to grapple with Catherine's mental state and mental abilities throughout the play Proof. She clearly wrestles with some of the same demons that her father had, and she tries her hardest to remain grounded in spite of the tendency towards mental illness.

While she shares many of his character traits, for the majority of the play it is not clear whether or not she has the same mathematical acuity as her father. Avoiding this subject, the play instead addresses her psychological state and discusses the negative aspects of her father's psyche that she inherited. At the very end, however, there is a small hint that she is a prodigy like her father. She reveals the thesis she wrote, and it is shown to be the complex mathematical proof discussed throughout the story. This shows that she truly has inherited her father's genius.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

This is the burning question for the characters in the play, especially for Catherine and her sister Claire. One of the first lines Catherine speaks is "I'M not crazy," directed to Hal when they discuss Robert's notebooks at the beginning of Act I.

Auburn presents differing attitudes to the question of what Catherine has inherited. Claire is almost dead certain that Catherine has inherited their father's mental instability (if not the graphomania yet). Hal is convinced that Catherine has inherited her father's genius but not the mental instability nor the graphomania (obsession with writing that comprises nonsense).

Catherine herself believes both things. She sees the things about herself, like her hyper-emotionalism and her excessive drive to solve an obtuse mathematical problem, as signs of her father's illness ... plus that she talks to her father after his death ... none of which help her know what to think about her inheritance: gift or curse.

Finally though, we discover Catherine herself has written the coveted mathematical proof:

HAL. You wrote this?
CATHERINE. Yes ... I started after I quit school. I finished a few months before Dad died.

Hal's persistence and patience wins out and the audience believes, even if Claire and Catherine don't, that, at least for the present, Catherine has inherited Robert's genius and that within that stable genius there is presently no room for mental instability.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial