From the description of Phoenix what do you conclude about her economic condition? How do you know that she has taken the path through the woods before? Is she accustomed to be alone? What do you...

From the description of Phoenix what do you conclude about her economic condition? How do you know that she has taken the path through the woods before?

Is she accustomed to be alone? What do you make of her speaking to animals,and of her imagining a boy offering her a piece of cake? What does her speech show about her education and background?

Expert Answers info

Jennings Williamson eNotes educator | Certified Educator

briefcaseTeacher (K-12)


calendarEducator since 2016

write6,413 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Arts

Given how happy she is with her two nickels, it seems safe to assume that Phoenix is quite poor. Also, she doesn't pay for her grandson's medicine; it is marked "Charity" by the nurse. Further, she wears a "red rag" tied on her head, rather than a hat, and wears a dress made of "bleached sugar sacks."

We know she has taken this path many times before because she knows the way by heart. Her eyesight has become poor, but she still can keep to the path. She says, "Up through pines . . . Now down through oaks." When she comes to the log laid across the creek, she says, "'Now comes the trial' . . . Then she opened her eyes and she was safe on the other side." In addition, the title tells us that the path is "worn," and we learn from the doctor's office that she comes every so often for the "soothing" medicine for her grandson.

She does seem accustomed to being alone, as she surmounts one obstacle after the next, without really seeming to be terribly set back. She does fall over once, but she certainly does not panic. Besides, she tells the women at the doctor's office that her grandson only has her, so it doesn't sound like she keeps company often.

I think she speaks to animals, just like she speaks to the scarecrow, because the world is so alive to her. She is quite aged and nearly blind, but she feels quite connected to the world around her, even being able to navigate it without the use of good eyesight. She is named Phoenix—a mythical bird who dies in flame and is reborn from its ashes—after all, and she seems to have some preternatural abilities herself.

Perhaps she imagines the boy offering her a slice of cake because he is symbolic of the promises made to African Americans after the Civil War, promises that were not kept. Likewise, when she reaches for what he's offered her, he disappears, along with the cake.

Phoenix does not have a real education. She tells the nurse that she "was too old at the Surrender" to go to school. She says, "I'm an old woman without an education." Her speech is simple and conversational, not polished, and this seems to confirm her report.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial
gbeatty eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2007

write2,654 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Science

We know that Phoenix is, if not out and out poor, right on the edge. Her dress is made from old sugar sacks, after all, and wears not a hat on her head but rather a "rag." She's rural, and likely poor.

As for the path, the title tells us it has been taken by someone often; it is "worn," after all. However, we also know more specifically; Phoenix talks to herself about how things always seem the same way every time she hits a specific point in the trail.

Further Reading:
check Approved by eNotes Editorial

Unlock This Answer Now