Franklin's goal here is not just moral behavior but moral perfection. Why do you think so few people today believe in such perfection?

2 Answers | Add Yours

akannan's profile pic

Ashley Kannan | Middle School Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

I would echo the sentiments previously discussed.  Might I also suggest that perfection has lost its sheen, in part, because we understand more of the frailties of human beings which makes it impossible, to a great extent.  For example, while Franklin was speaking from a supposed moral perfectionist position, his own social setting allowed slavery, subjugation of women, and denial of voice from the lower class.  We also know that Franklin himself engaged in activities that we now would deem as far from perfect.  Part of the reason that we have lost a sense of perfection is because with the more information and understanding we have gained, such intense scrutiny has allowed us to see faults and shortcomings in such a light that we have discredited those who have suggested that perfection is a reality.  Analyzing Franklin in this light translates into doing the same with others.  Those who have professed to possess a vision of perfection have articulated this in the face of striving for a comedic ends, unable or unwilling to acknowledge its inevitable tragedy.  We have begun to understand that while perfection might not be the ultimate end, "getting it right" could be a more worthy goal.  It is for this reason that Franklin, himself, and the other framers listed as the first goal of the Constitution to "form a more perfect union," implying that democracy is an experiment where perfection is impossible, but "getting it more right" is in ofitself a more worthwhile pursuit.

pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

This is, of course, a matter of opinion.  I'd offer the following ideas:

  1. People now are more realistic and less romantic than Franklin was.  We know full well today that it is impractical to expect moral perfection.  We may aim to be as good as possible, but we know we can't attain perfection.
  2. This is an opposite idea to #1.  Perhaps it is because people are less religious and more self-indulgent than before.  Perhaps we no longer care if we are moral but care only for what we want to do.
  3. A sort of contrary argument here -- how do we know people today believe in this perfection less than they did in Franklin's day?  Just because he said he was trying for this doesn't mean anyone else was.  And I have no way of knowing how many people I see each day believe that they could be perfect if they tried hard enough.

We’ve answered 318,989 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question