Explain whether Jonas's assignment could be considered an honor or a punishment.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Jonas 's assignment as the next Receiver of Memory is considered a special honor because it is a prestigious position that is very important to the community. Jonas's community is founded on the concepts of Sameness, and it is his job, as the Receiver of Memory, to contain and preserve...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

Jonas's assignment as the next Receiver of Memory is considered a special honor because it is a prestigious position that is very important to the community. Jonas's community is founded on the concepts of Sameness, and it is his job, as the Receiver of Memory, to contain and preserve humanity's past memories. Jonas is essentially responsible for his community's stability, comfort, and safety. If something were to happen to Jonas, his difficult memories would return to the community, and chaos would ensue. Jonas's assignment also gives him wisdom, and he has the unique opportunity to consult the ruling Committee of Elders on certain policy issues. It also takes a special person, with the Capacity to See Beyond, to be assigned to such a prominent position in the community.

Despite the honorable nature of Jonas's significant assignment, it could also be considered a punishment, because he suffers from the weight and trauma of past memories. Jonas's assignment is extremely painful, and he is required to experience humanity's most disturbing memories without the use of medication. In addition to Jonas's painful experiences, he is also prohibited from speaking about his assignment, which makes him feel extremely lonely and depressed.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team