Explain one factor that led to the national government having significantly more power than the states.Explain one factor that led to the national government having significantly more power than...

Explain one factor that led to the national government having significantly more power than the states.

Explain one factor that led to the national government having significantly more power than the states.

Asked on by ilovemybby

3 Answers | Add Yours

larrygates's profile pic

larrygates | College Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

The primary factor that led to the Federal Government having more power than the states was the failure of the Articles of Confederation Government. After the Declaration and during the Revolutionary War, the States were jealous of their own sovereignty, and did not wish to be subjected to another strong government as they had been under the British. For that reason, the Articles specifically stated that each state would be sovereign. It proved unworkable, however. The Confederation Government had no way to enforce its policies, had no taxing authority, and were difficult to administer. States printed their own money, taxed goods produced in other states, and created general havoc. It is no coincidence that the preamble to the Constitution notes the need to form a "more perfect" Union.

pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

One factor that has led to the national government having significantly more power than the state governments has been the increasing complexity and interconnection of the American economy.

The Constitution gave Congress the exclusive right to regulate interstate commerce.  Over time, this right has given the federal government more and more power over the states.  When the Constitution was written, most economic activity took place within states and so the federal government had very little regulating to do.  Nowadays, though, almost all economic activity involves interstate commerce.  A hamburger that you buy at McDonald's for example, will have beef from one state, tomatoes from another, a bun made from wheat from yet another state.  All of that has been transported across state lines.  This means that it is all regulated by the federal government.

As the American economy has grown bigger and more interconnected, the federal government's right to regulate interstate commerce has greatly increased its power relative to that of the states.

bloo2701's profile pic

bloo2701 | Student, Grade 9 | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

the necessary and proper clause

it is an elastic clause so the govt takes more control in some cases and less in another bcuz the constitution was based on interpretation and everything not mentioned(basically almost nothing with interpretation) goes to states

We’ve answered 318,984 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question