Explain Montag's memory of the sand dune in Fahrenheit 451.  Why do you think the title of this part of the novel is named "The Sieve and the sand"?

Expert Answers
schulzie eNotes educator| Certified Educator

When Montag was a child, a cousin challenged him to fill a sieve, which is a kitchen utensil used to drain items and has a lot of holes in it, with sand.  As he filled the sieve, the sand drained out. He was promised a dime if he could fill the sieve.

"And the faster he poured, the faster it sieved through with a hot whispering." (pg 78)

The memory came back to him as he is sitting on a train heading for Faber's house.  He has suddenly come to the realization that books are important and that men spent a lot of time writing down ideas and those ideas needed to be saved.  He makes an analogy with the sand and sieve to his efforts to memorize the Bible.

"If you read fast and read all, maybe some of the sand will stay in the sieve.  But he read and the words fell through..." (pg 78)

He realized that in a few hours he would have to turn the book over to Beatty, and he only had a few hours to memorize as much as he could.  He willed himself to memorize as much as he could.  At the end of the book, when he meets Granger, he says,

"I thought I had part of the Book of Ecclesiastes and maybe a little of Revelation, but I haven't even that now." (pg 150)

Granger assures him that when it is needed, he will remember.  He does remember after the bomb hits.  He becomes the Book of Ecclesiastes.

gmuss25 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

At the beginning of Part Two, which is entitled "The Sieve and the Sand," Montag attempts to read scripture while riding a distracting subway train on his way to see Faber. On the train, Montag recalls a memory from his childhood when he visited the beach. At the beach, Montag's cousin bet him a dime that he could not fill up a sieve with sand. As Montag poured the hot sand into the sieve, it sifted through the screen at the bottom of the sieve. The faster Montag poured, the faster the sand sifted through the bottom. Essentially, the same thing happens to Montag's mind regarding his ability to comprehend the texts he is reading on the distracting train. The faster Montag reads, the less information he can obtain. The annoying Denham's Dentrifice advertisement continues to avert his attention, and he is unable to comprehend anything that he reads. The title of Part Two alludes to Montag's childhood memory, which metaphorically represents his struggle to comprehend texts.  

happygirl4444 | Student

Thank you!(:

 

Read the study guide:
Fahrenheit 451

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question