In Ellison's short story "Battle Royal," how can the dream at the end of the story be related to the major incidents that precede it?

Expert Answers
jerseygyrl1983 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The clowns likely represent distortions of humanity. During the battle royal, the young black men in the ring are egged on by the white men, who use pejoratives that were routinely hurled at black people, terms that have little to do with how black people perceive themselves: "Sambo" and "coon," for example.

When it is time for the narrator to give his speech, having survived the onslaught of violence in which they forced his participation, the spectators struggle to hear him and then censor his speech. This is because the protagonist has stepped out of his role as a "clown," or a figure of self-mockery, and now wishes to focus their attention on his concerns as a human being. He makes the Freudian slip of calling for "social equality" instead of repeating Booker T. Washington's dictum of "social responsibility," disorienting the white men in the crowd. They insist on seeing the narrator as an object of their amusement, while his comment, however unintentional, asserts his individuality and humanity. 

The suitcase in the dream is a simulacrum of the one that he was given as a prize after the fight. What was not previously mentioned is that, after following his grandfather's instruction to open the suitcase and "read what was inside," he finds "an official envelope stamped with the state seal" and opens it to find more envelopes, ad infinitum. It is significant that the envelope is stamped with a state seal, indicating that the subjugation and manipulation of the narrator, and the other black men in the ring, is not only by design but is officially sanctioned.

Moreover, most of the envelopes contain nothing but are instead promises of some reward that the narrator will never receive. It is only the final one that contains a message—short but engraved "in letters of gold." The significance of the engraving is that the message is permanent. The gold engraving is yet another form of mockery, given that gold signifies wealth and first-class status—again, social benefits that, according to the message, the narrator will never enjoy.

meg526 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The narrator's dream in "Battle Royal" contains many images that reflect the events of the previous evening. The circus clowns represent the young men who were forced to participate in the battle for the entertainment of the white crowd. The grandfather refuses to laugh at the clowns because, the narrator recalls, he regretted being so mild-mannered in his life; refusing to laugh is a show of resistance against those who insist he or his grandson must perform in a particular way.

The envelopes are a literal reference to the envelope and scholarship the narrator receives as victor. However, the grandfather laughs when the narrator opens envelope after envelope—symbolizing endless tasks or obstacles to the black man's success, put in place by the white man—only to find a note that instructs an unknown schoolmaster to "keep this boy [the narrator] running." This is a callback to the events of the battle royal in that the narrator and his cohorts were invited to the hotel under false pretenses and put through one humiliation after another.

Even though the narrator received a scholarship and was allowed to make his speech, these victories were at the expense of his dignity—a callback to the grandfather's deathbed laments. The grandfather's laughter could be interpreted as the narrator's own realization that he will always be running, even when he seems to be victorious, because of how society views him, rather than as the grandfather laughing at his grandson's humiliation.

cybil eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Circus imagery, represented by the clowns in the dream, is significant in the Battle Royal in that the the black boys, who are forced to entertain the white men, are treated as if they are no better than animals. The grandfather's advice was to "live with your head in the lion's mouth," thus comparing the white man to a lion tamer. The white stripper is described as having hair "yellow that like of a circus kewpie doll"; the young men are treated like "circus clowns." One is even characterized as "glistening with sweat like a circus seal."

The dream reveals his grandfather who "refused to laugh at the clowns no matter what they did" because they represent blacks forced by white society to "perform" humiliating acts to entertain the whites. The grandfather knows they are his own people, forced into acts of submission, just as the boys were in the Battle Royal. The seemingly endless series of envelopes implies that white society will continue to make a clown of Invisible Man.

Read the study guide:
Battle Royal; or, The Invisible Man

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question