During a scene in Gattaca, Vincent’s parents visited a doctor who specialized in child conception to select for the best traits for his future brother. They hoped that his brother would have the best possible chances for a successful life. Some of the traits mentioned in Gattaca included intelligence, height, and any possibility of inheritable diseases. In the future, if parents decide to have a child one day and are given the opportunity to select for special traits, should they? Why or why not?

Selecting special traits for a child can be a good thing because it could help ensure the child does not suffer from diseases, fits in with social standards, and excels in school and work. However, selecting special traits can be a bad thing because it can lead to less genetic variation in society and cause strained relationships between parents and their children.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The answer to this question depends in part on people’s personal views. I will discuss some reasons why people think parents should select special traits and why others think parents should not.

If parents could select the traits their baby will have it could help ensure their child will not...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

The answer to this question depends in part on people’s personal views. I will discuss some reasons why people think parents should select special traits and why others think parents should not.

If parents could select the traits their baby will have it could help ensure their child will not struggle with certain physical or mental illnesses. For instance, if they knew their baby was at risk for inheriting a life-threatening disease then the ability to not select that trait could save the child pain and suffering. Parents also might want to select traits that help ensure their child will fit into what is considered “normal” in their society. For example, selecting an average height might help ensure the child will fit in with their peers rather than stand out for being especially tall or especially short. Selecting a child’s intelligence can also help set the child on the path to success. It could help ensure the child does well in school, goes to a good college, and can excel in a great career.

On the other hand, many people think that parents should not select special traits for their children. One of the main reasons for this argument is that selecting traits interferes with the process of natural selection. Weeding out traits that do not align with social standards will result in less genetic variation in society, which will eventually weaken people’s ability to adapt to changes in the environment. Selecting traits also redefines the relationship between parents and their children. It allows parents to plan what they want their child’s life to look like and create an idea in their mind about what their child will be like. The child might feel immense pressure to fit that mold their parents picked out for them and might end up disappointing their parents with some of their actions, interests, and even physical characteristics.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team