Why does Gretchen receive salvation at the end of Faust Part I?

Quick answer:

In the original Urfaust, Gretchen (Eve) doesn't receive salvation or is not even in the play. The Voice From Above was not a part of the play, and Gretchen's salvation was added after Goethe had finished writing the original version of "Dungeon." The plot development for Faust pivots around Gretchen's importance and salvation.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

This is actually a complex and difficult question. If we look for the answer from a textual perspective, we have to note that when Goethe finished the text of "Dungeon" in 1774, the Voice (From Above) was not in the scene. The voice and the message of salvation were added...

This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

at a later date during one of Goethe's several additions toFaust I & II. So in the original Faust, the Urfaust, Gretchen did not receive salvation, or at least, she would not have received salvation then. We don't know what would have followed if Goethe had not  added her salvation there, because later additions rejected the style of emotional frenzy with which he started and adopted Classical style, thus creating a very different work from the one begun.

If we look for the answer from characterization and plot perspectives, we might have an easier time sorting Goethe's reasoning out. Looking at plot, the far-reaching plot included the ultimate salvation of Faust in Part II. Gretchen's salvation is a plot device whereby Faust's own salvation is achieved. (1) Faust is only tormented by Mephistopheles because God allows it in the Prologue as a wager between Himself and Mephisto. God is certain that Faust is a good man who will in the end serve Him. God turns out to be right as is seen in the end of Part II (Midnight, Outer Court). (2) Gretchen's salvation foreshadows what is to come for Faust by way of intervention on his behalf in Part II when Gretchen prays for him in Heaven and Choirs of Angels lift him up.

Looking at it from characterization, (1) if God sees Faust as a good man though presently confused, "Though he’s still confused at how to serve me," then God must see Gretchen as good. (2) Gretchen sincerely rejects Mephisto's presence at her dungeon prison and commends herself to God, both of which are significant for her salvation:

MargaretWhat rises in the doorway, here?Him! Him! Send him away!Why is he here in this holy place?He wants me!God of Judgement! To you, myself I give!

(3) As you say, she has been the manipulated plaything of a demon from hell and, though she has always disliked and been suspicious of him, she has no more power to withstand Mephistopheles, or his schemes for Faust to follow through on, than she might have to resist a scorpion in the night.

Margarete You can see he’s not at all in sympathy:It’s written on his forehead even,That there’s no spirit of love within....Yet I’m stifled in his presence.

Therefore she is saved because she sincerely believes in God and salvation through Christ; she sincerely recognizes and rejects the powers of Lucifer in Mephisto; she sincerely submits herself to God's care, for good or for bad; she was clearly overpowered by and wickedly manipulated by the schemes and influences of the demon Mephistopheles. In addition, Goethe's plot development for Faust pivots around Gretchen's importance and salvation.

Approved by eNotes Editorial