Does anyone have an interesting thesis idea along the heroism theme or masculinity theme for The Red Badge of Courage?  I really need help with a good suggestion on making a concise argument...

Does anyone have an interesting thesis idea along the heroism theme or masculinity theme for The Red Badge of Courage?

 

I really need help with a good suggestion on making a concise argument while using a single clear critical approach throughout my paper.

I have an idea for a thesis along the lines that states that Stephen Crane questions the idea of heroism in war through Henry Fleming.

I'm not convinced on going in this direction yet though.

Asked on by lr009

1 Answer | Add Yours

jk180's profile pic

James Kelley | College Teacher | (Level 1) Educator

Posted on

You're going in the right direction, I think. It's been a very, very long time since I last read that novel, but when I did last read and teach it, I was struck by how often the novel builds up the idea of patriotism and of male achievement in war (mostly in the fantasies of the young male protagonist) only to let all those ideals fail in the moment they’re most needed and to show the young man (Henry's often not called by name in the novel) again and again failing in his courage or fortitude or whatever you want to call it.

You may be interested in exploring how Henry develops a fuller awareness of things once he’s away from the crowd of men, when he is isolated and exposed to the horror, for example, of the corpse in the forest. The alchemical transformation in the final lines of the novel, the change in the imagery from lead (rainclouds) to gold (the sun’s rays), may signal that some sort of transformation in Henry has indeed taken place and that he has finally become a man. In the end, then, you may see the novel as in some ways criticizing the ideals of “manliness” and “patriotism” yet at the same time embracing some notion of what a “real man” is, someone who alone faces a crisis and survives.

We’ve answered 318,989 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question