Discuss the role of Charley and Bernard in relation to their influence in the Loman family in Death of a Salesman.

Charley and Bernard are foils to Willy and Biff Loman and portray the positive aspects of the American Dream in Death of a Salesman, which is the popular concept that Miller critiques throughout the course of the play. As successful, rational businessmen, Charley and Bernard have attained the American Dream, unlike Willy and Biff, who are completely delusional and lack the necessary attributes to attain financial success.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles
The characters of Charley and Bernard portray the positive aspects of the American Dream and serve as foils to Willy Loman and his unsuccessful son Biff. Throughout the play, Miller critiques the capitalist system and portrays the American Dream as an illusory concept that people like Willy, Biff, Happy, and...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial
The characters of Charley and Bernard portray the positive aspects of the American Dream and serve as foils to Willy Loman and his unsuccessful son Biff. Throughout the play, Miller critiques the capitalist system and portrays the American Dream as an illusory concept that people like Willy, Biff, Happy, and countless others cannot attain. However, Charley and Bernard's characters prove that the American Dream still exists for those willing to compete, apply themselves, and take advantage of opportunities. By depicting Charley and Bernard's success, Miller's work becomes more realistic and well-rounded. Miller illustrates that the American Dream is not completely futile and unattainable by depicting Charley and Bernard's success.

Charley and his son also act as foils to Willy and Biff. Charley is a successful businessman who goes out of his way to help Willy by lending him money and offering him a job. Charley also recognizes the necessary attributes to succeed in business and has instilled those positive qualities in Bernard. Although Bernard is not a physically imposing figure like Biff, his intelligence, determination, and hard work has paid off. Bernard is depicted as a humble, successful lawyer, while Biff is portrayed as a conflicted, lost individual without a definite goal or purpose in life. As foils, Charley and Bernard's characters accentuate the negative qualities of Willy and Biff Loman.

Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Charley and Bernard act as foils to Willy and Biff Loman throughout the play and attempt to help the Loman family numerous times. Unlike Willy, Charley is a successful, hard-working man, who instilled positive traits in his son as a child. Charley is a practical, selfless man, who offers Willy money, advice, and a job throughout the play.

Bernard contrasts with Biff Loman and is a successful lawyer. Unlike Biff, Bernard was an intelligent, dedicated student, who graduated college and became a well-known lawyer. Bernard's hard work paid off, and he runs into Willy before he presents his case in front of the Supreme Court.

Miller uses Charley and Bernard to emphasize Willy and Biff's failures by contrasting the two father-son relationships. Despite Willy's erratic behavior, short temper, and sensitive personality, Charley is kind to Willy and tries his best to help him out. As a child, Bernard attempted to help Biff out by allowing him to copy off his tests. Despite their efforts, Charley and Bernard are not able to help Willy from living a delusional life, which results in his tragic death.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

If Willy Loman and his messed up family represent the downside of the American Dream, then Charley and Bernard are its sunnier side. While Miller is keen to present a critical portrait of the dark underbelly of American capitalism, he realizes that it's also important to show the upside if he's to give us a more rounded, more dramatically satisfying picture. After all, drama is fundamentally about conflict; and as well as Willy's inner conflict, and the conflict between himself and his sons, there's also the much wider conflict between Willy and the system of capitalism. He passionately believes in this system, though it continues to destroy him, little by little.

In order to make this conflict more effective it's necessary for Miller to show that the system by which Willy lives and dies is not just a sham. Willy may become increasingly delusional as the play progresses, but there's just enough truth in the American Dream to keep someone in his situation striving hard against the odds. Therein lies much of the play's drama. The capitalist system, though ultimately destructive of Willy and countless others, does often provide opportunities to those who have the wherewithal to make it in this competitive system. Hence the need for Charley and Bernard; they provide a glimpse into what Willy and his sons might have been.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Charley and Bernard play an important role in the play Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller because they serve as foils of Willy and his two sons. This means that Charley, a successful man, and Bernard (his equally successful son) allow the audience to contrast the reality of Willy's foolish life versus what could have been if Willy had developed a normal relationship with Biff and Happy.

We know that Charley is Willy's neighbor and perhaps his only true friend. Without complaint, he continuously offers Willy a job and gives him money every week for Willy to take to his family. This, of course, he does secretly and to save Willy's reputation with his family.

Moreover, we also know that Charley was the only attendant at Willy's funeral. We see how Charley seems to have a deeper grasp of Willy's personality and of his situation. Yet, in contrast to Willy, Charley would never be capable of praising himself nor feel superior to anybody.

Conclusively, the role of Charley and Bernard is to foil the Loman's dysfunctional family, and to serve as the only supportive link between Willy and the real world. If it weren't for Charley, Willy would have not been able to feed his family, we assume. Also, without Charley's support, the Lomans would have found themselves desolate at Willy's funeral. Hence, Charley and Bernard represent Willy's only real support system, and are the best example of a true friendship.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team