Diamond reports that after the original publication of Guns, Germs and Steel, Bill Gates and other American corporate executives communicated with him that they were interested in how his...

Diamond reports that after the original publication of Guns, Germs and Steel, Bill Gates and other American corporate executives communicated with him that they were interested in how his arguments about the factors leading to the relative success of particular societies might apply to success in the business world. Which of the following statements is TRUE with regard to Diamond’s principle of “optimal fragmentation”?

  a. A highly centralized society, such as that of China, is best suited to competition in the global arena today.
 
  b. A company broken into competing groups is really not likely to survive.
 
  c. Europe’s combination of political fragmentation and some degree of centralized direction is advantageous for innovation.
 
  d. The high degree of fragmentation of India is a major advantage for that society’s capacity for technological innovation.

Asked on by capima

1 Answer | Add Yours

pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

Of the options presented here, the best answer is Option C.  To understand why this is so, we must pay attention to both parts of the term “optimal fragmentation.”

In Guns, Germs, and Steel, Diamond argues that China lost its lead over Europe because it was too unified.  He says that China did not have to compete with anyone and that it, therefore, was not forced to make any progress.  By contrast, Europe was fragmented and the competition caused by the fragmentation forced Europeans to get ahead technologically and in other ways.  This would imply that fragmentation is a good thing.

However, we must remember that the word “optimal” is also part of this formula.  Diamond is not simply saying that fragmentation is always good.  Instead, he says that fragmentation is good up to a degree.  For example, in this interview, he says that India was “hyperfragmented” and that this fragmentation was a real problem for the subcontinent. 

Clearly, Diamond does not believe that either A or D is true.  That leaves C as the most plausible answer to this question.

Sources:

We’ve answered 318,990 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question