In Cry, the Beloved Country, what does this quote mean? "The church has a voice but no deeds" and how is it contradicted in the story?

Expert Answers
mejwestut eNotes educator| Certified Educator

An additional perspective comes from Alan Paton who was a very religous man and felt that religion could bring all men together. (See the foreward and introduction in the book.)

The author's point-of-view regarding the unifying force of religion can be seen in the relationship between Kumalo and Jarvis. While very strict racial lines are drawn between the two men, the church helps bring them together for a common purpose--the native people living on the land.

The voice could be seen as Kumalo--his deeds are yet to be proven. (As seen in Kumalo's relationship with his son, his wife, and un-born grandchild.)

alexb2 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The quote means that the church can talk a good game, but does not act when necessary. It is not able to affect the social change is preaches.

One example of the church having a positive role in healing people comes when Steven opens his church to Jarvis in the rain. The openness of the church (literally and figuratively) is important in showing how the church can act in small ways.

belovedcountry | Student

Place of woman the Novel