tablesetting complete with forks, knives, and spoons, and a baby on the plate in the center above the words "A Modest Proposal"

A Modest Proposal

by Jonathan Swift

Start Free Trial

Consider the additional proposal Swift mentions in paragraph 17 of "A Modest Proposal." Explain the rhetorical strategy at work in that paragraph.

In paragraph 17 of "A Modest Proposal," Swift's narrator mentions the proposal he has heard from a friend to sell poor children aged 12 to 14 as food for the rich to make up for a shortage in the supply of venison. Swift's rhetorical strategy is to use hyperbole to illustrate the cruelty of reducing the "poor" to no more than economic widgets who need to turn a profit.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In this paragraph, the speaker mentions another proposal that he heard from a person he holds in high esteem as both a patriotic and virtuous individual. This man suggests that the shortage of venison in the country might be alleviated by selling the bodies of poor children between the ages...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

In this paragraph, the speaker mentions another proposal that he heard from a person he holds in high esteem as both a patriotic and virtuous individual. This man suggests that the shortage of venison in the country might be alleviated by selling the bodies of poor children between the ages of 12 and 14 as a substitute form of "venison." He argues that these children are often starving to death anyway, and this sale would both raise money and save the parents or relatives the problem of having to dispose of the children's corpses after they starve. However, the speaker rejects this idea, not out of compassion, but because he believes the meat of the boys will be too tough to be tasty, and he believes the girls are so close to puberty and childbearing that they would be better put to use birthing babies to be sold a gourmet delicacies.

After dispensing with the idea on the basis of its impracticality, the speaker then comments:

Besides, it is not improbable that some scrupulous people might be apt to censure such a practice, (although indeed very unjustly) as a little bordering upon cruelty, which, I confess, hath always been with me the strongest objection against any project, how well soever intended.

Swift's essay means to show what happens to a person's moral compass when he begins to look at a certain class of people, such as the "poor," as a problem rather than as fully human beings. Once a group becomes an economic problem to be solved, it is easy to dehumanize them. Swift uses the rhetorical strategy of introducing ever more absurd levels of hyperbole or exaggeration to illustrate this. It is exaggeratedly inhumane to think of using pre-adolescent children for food, and absurd, having proposed cannibalism, to protest that "cruelty" is his "strongest objection" to any project. Swift uses hyperbole so the reader will easily grasp the gap between what the speaker proposes and any normal concept of kindness or compassion. In a bigger picture sense, Swift wants the reader to abandon the idea of having to economically justify aid to the poor rather than simply giving them the help they need.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In this paragraph, Swift outlines a satirically logical argument. Obtaining this idea from a friend, Swift notes that it is possible to replace the overtaxed venison demand with the bodies of children ages 12-14. After all, these children are starving anyway, so this would put their bodies to good purpose. However, he notes that this isn't the most practical age to obtain children for food purposes; the male bodies, he has been told by an American, are simply too lean due to exercise, and fattening them up doesn't change the lean muscle mass. And females of this age, he reasons, don't make an excellent choice for consumption, either; they will soon be of age to become (food) breeders themselves, so it is wasteful to eat them just a few years before they can become of consistent service to the upper classes.

The primary rhetorical strategy Swift uses in this paragraph (and elsewhere in his satirical essay) is logos. He approaches the subject from a place of (false) logic, showing how it just makes practical sense for the upper classes to physically consume the poor since they have been metaphorically consuming them for years. Swift's detached and systematic approach to the advantages of eating the children of the poor shocked readers of his time—which was exactly his intent. Trying to reason with the upper classes on the need for reform in other ways hadn't garnered the attention Swift desired, so he used a logic-filled essay to bring needed attention to the plight of Ireland's poor.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The speaker begins the paragraph by assuring us of the "virtues" of his friend who has offered a "refinement upon [his] scheme." He believes that he can enhance the credibility of his friend by assuring readers that he is "a true lover of his country" and of his expertise on the subjects of meat and children. This virtuous and knowledgeable friend suggests that a lack of venison can be remedied by consuming children between the ages of twelve and fourteen, children who would otherwise starve from lack of work. This friend, apparently, has "frequent experience" consuming this kind of child, and, from speaking with the narrator, the narrator believes that meat from boys is too tough and lean, and it would be inadvisable to eat girls because they will soon become "breeders" who can produce more babies. The narrator also declares that this practice, of eating older children, strikes him as cruel, and this "hath always been with [him] the strongest objection against any project," he claims.

In this way, the narrator hopes to increase his own credibility and enhance our view of the justness of his proposal: this wonderful, intelligent man has proposed something that even the narrator finds somewhat cruel. This argument seems designed by him to elevate him in our estimation by relying on ethos. We see where he draws the line, and he attempts to convince us of the justice of this line, as it makes him appear to be more reasonable. The more reasonable and just and ethical he appears, the more apt we are to agree with his original proposal.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The narrator of this essay develops his plan to single-handedly solve the Irish famine problem through advancing a solution to the shortage of venison. He mentions how an American acquaintance he had assured him that this lack of venison could be solved if teenage children were to be eaten:

He said, that many gentlemen of this kingdom, having of late destroyed their deer, he conceived that the want of venison might be well supply'd by the bodies of young lads and maidens, not exceeding fourteen years of age, nor under twelve; so great a number of both sexes in every country being now ready to starve for want of work and service...

Note the justification he provides for this suggestion: there are so many young boys and girls of this age who are willing to "starve for want of work and service" that this would be a good solution to the lack of venison, as it would take these spare bodies and convert them into a form that would mean they no longer needed to starve and needed to be provided for, because they would be eaten. Rhetorically, Swift uses a monstrous argument conveyed in a serious and sincere tone to point out the monstrous attitude of the British towards the Irish famine. It is this that makes this essay such an effective persuasive document, as it condemns the British through their own indifference to the situation. Swift risks being labelled monstrous in order to point out the monstrosity of his audience.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team