Philosophy Questions and Answers

Start Your Free Trial

Compare and contrast utilitarian and deontological reasoning.

Expert Answers info

ac12 eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2016

write148 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, Science, and History

We can make the distinction clearer with the aid of a thought experiment.

Imagine that you are asked by someone to shoot one person. If you do not do as you are asked, the person asking you to shoot that person will shoot fifteen other people. What should you do? What is the morally correct action?

Now the utilitarian is concerned solely with the outcomes or the consequences of the action. The right action is the one from which we may derive the most utility. Thus, a simple act utilitarian would say that you ought to shoot that one person, since one person dead is a better outcome than fifteen people dead. This way of thinking has its origins in John Stuart Mill’s On Utilitarianism.

The deontologist, on the other hand, might argue that one has a perfect duty to others not to kill them and the right action is one that involves fulfilling one’s perfect duties. This is the language used by Immanuel Kant in his Critique of Practical Reason. The deontologist would claim that one ought to do has...

(The entire section contains 2 answers and 551 words.)

Unlock This Answer Now

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

pohnpei397 eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write35,413 answers

starTop subjects are History, Literature, and Social Sciences

check Approved by eNotes Editorial