Compare And Contrast Directional Selection And Disruptive Selection

Compare and contrast directional selection and disruptive selection in biology.

Expert Answers
justaguide eNotes educator| Certified Educator

In nature, evolution takes place through a process called selection. In a group of organisms of the same species, differences occur in how prominent particular traits are. The offspring of organisms with traits that facilitate survival in the environment they are in have a higher chance of surviving. This process of selection gradually increases the number of organisms with particular traits and the species evolves.

Directional selection is said to occur when one of the extremes of a trait distribution is eliminated. For instance, consider the trait length of a plant's root. If the plant is in an environment where the ground water level has fallen, only the plants that have long roots are able to reach the water and survive. The plants with shorter roots are not able to survive and this changes the genetic profile of future generations of the plant such that the length of their roots increases.

For any trait of organisms belonging to a particular species, there are some that have extreme values of the relevant trait. Disruptive selection is said to occur when these organisms survive and those that do not lie at the extremes are eliminated. For example, consider a species of animal with different height. If organisms that are extremely short and those that are extremely tall are in a more favorable position to survive than those with height lying in the middle, there is a disruptive selection as organisms that lie in the middle of the trait are eliminated.

thetall eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Natural selection ensures that the environment maintains its carrying capacity or balance. During natural selection, organisms with favorable traits supported by the environment have a higher chance of survival within their environment. The dominant traits are passed along the successive organisms to ensure the coming generations continue to exist.

Disruptive selection and Directional selection are types of selection that occur in organisms within an environment. Disruptive selection occurs by favoring both extreme traits in a spectrum, while directional selection occurs when only a single extreme trait is favored in an organism within its environment.

The traits have to be observed against the organism’s immediate environment. For instance, in an environment where only black and brown cats can hunt effectively, any other color of cats within the environment will be eliminated, demonstrating a disruptive selection of the cats and proving that the black and brown cats exhibit the extreme dominant traits. Directional selection, on the other hand, occurs only when the black cats are favored within the environment. Thus, both the brown and other colored cats will be eliminated from such an environment.

CaitlynnReeves | Student

Directional selection occurs when one extreme of a trait is favored. For instance, if a white coat was favored over both a black and gray colored coat. This would skew the population's genetic make up so that if you were to graph it, most of the population would fall under a bell curve at one end of the graph. 

Disruptive selection is where any two extremes of a trait are favored. (Perhaps a flower being either red or white was beneficial over being pink). Then the population would fall under two seperate bell curves creating a dip in the middle of the graph. 

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question