Question

Compare and contrast the characters of Bernard Marx and Helmholtz Watson in Brave New World.

Accepted Answer

These two characters are similar in that they are both unhappy with the society in which they live.  They are different, however, because Helmholtz's unhappiness is more principled than Bernard's.
Bernard is unhappy because he can't get into society.  Society rejects him because of his looks, so he is not popular.  When Bernard gets the chance to enter society's notice because of John the Savage, he takes the chance and acts in the way society expects him to.  Bernard hates the idea of being exiled.
Conversely, Helmholtz is unhappy because he dislikes the restrictions society puts on his thoughts and his expression.  He is the perfect physical specimen and can easily be accepted by society.  Yet he rejects the society because of his principles.  When Helmholtz is going to be exiled, he accepts his fate willingly because he truly dislikes the society.  
So both men dislike their society, but Helmholtz's objections are principled compared to Bernard's.

Answer

Both men are in some sense rebels, disbelievers in the ethic of the Society. Helmholtz, however, is more of a rebel by choice than Bernard, who seems at times to have had the character of a subversive imposed upon him by circumstances.
Much is made throughout the story of Bernard's unusual and unimposing appearance. The planned hierarchical nature of the Society is based largely upon intelligence, with the Alphas having the highest IQ's and the Epsilons the lowest. But there is also a physical dimension to the Society's eugenics program. If we especially consider how much of their thinking revolves around sex, the physical perfection of their "products"—human beings—is a component of their planning. Bernard is short and unattractive, in spite of being an Alpha-plus. People speculate that in his case something went wrong with the normal in vitro process, resulting in the stunting of his growth or the cause of some other defect.
Bernard is thus the Other (rivaling the status of John, the "Savage," in this regard) in a society where such people are not supposed to exist. If he's on the outside looking in, it's because he can't help it in some sense. Helmholtz, on the other hand, is attractive and seems to have everything going for him, but is dissatisfied with the Society anyway. One can interpret his non-conformism as "purer" than Bernard's.
It's also true that Bernard doesn't come across as a very admirable character. He seems more of an attempt by Huxley at creating an object of humor, with his insecurity and fretting, than a serious rebel. But the humor aspect of Brave New World permeates every part of the novel. Though it is a dystopia, it's also a dark comedy in a way; this is the diametric opposite of Orwell's 1984, though both books are usually seen as the iconic anti-utopian novels of the twentieth century. Bernard is comical, unlike Helmholtz, but this, and especially his general Otherness, should not disqualify his subversiveness from being seen by us as basically genuine and true.

Answer

At the beginning of the novel, Bernard and Helmholtz are already friends, which means they have spent a lot of time together discussing their philosophies on life. Since they are both Alphas, they are very intelligent and need academic stimulation. Bernard works in the Psychology Bureau and Helmholtz works as a writer for Feelies and other unintelligent venues. They are both intelligent enough to have intellectually stimulating conversations and this is why they spend time together. They have recently challenged themselves to act more like adults, rather than children, by restricting their personal impulses. For example, Bernard wants to focus on Lenina, one mate, and Helmholtz wants to restrict all women because they are distracting and he's searching for something profound to write about.
Unfortunately, Bernard's commitment to what he has discussed with his friend is not as strong as Helmholtz's. Once Bernard gets a little bit of popularity, it goes to his head and he becomes the type of person he complained about before. Helmholtz actually pinpoints the similarities and differences between himself and Bernard as follows:

"He liked Bernard; he was grateful to him for being the only man of his acquaintance with whom he could talk about the subjects he felt to be important. Nevertheless, there were things in Bernard which he hated. This boasting, for example. And the outbursts of an abject self-pity with which it alternated. And his deplorable habit of being bold after the event, and full, in absence, of the most extraordinary presence of mind. He hated these things--just because he liked Bernard" (116).

Helmholtz is secure, humble and patient; but Bernard is insecure, arrogant, and pitiful. Not only that, but Helmholtz is tall, handsome, and can have any girl he ever wants, but Bernard is short, eccentric, and not as handsome.

Answer

Bernard and Helmholtz are similar in that they both feel distressed within their societies. They both express their criticism towards the World State and its operations. They both are unable to fit within their social positions. Their differences come in how they feel the distress. Bernard fights for acceptance by the community while Helmholtz does not really want to belong in that particular community.
The difference between them is that Bernard, even though he fights for acceptance, is weak, unattractive and not as intelligent. Helmholtz is the perfect society’s perfect human specimen; he is strong, attractive, and very intelligent. Bernard is shallow, and he is in pursuit of popularity within his community as seen when he takes full advantage to live the popular life after coming back with John the Savage. Helmholtz is not bothered with popularity or with society’s standards and instead thinks that popularity and those standards are vain.

Brave New World

Compare and contrast the characters of Bernard Marx and Helmholtz Watson in Brave New World.

Expert Answers

Unlock This Answer Now

Related Questions

Why are Bernard Marx and Helmholtz Watson expelled from civilization in Brave New World?

In Brave New World, why do Bernard Marx and Helmholtz Watson feel out of place in society?

What do Bernard Marx and Helmholtz Watson have in common in Brave New World by Aldous Huxley?

How is Bernard Marx different from his associates in Brave New World?

What happens to Bernard and Helmholtz at the end of the Brave New World?