What are some things Chris McCandless and Gene Rosellini have in common? What are some things that make them different from one another?

Expert Answers info

Jonathan Beutlich eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2014

write5,639 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, Science, and History

Author Jon Krakauer focuses on the similarities between Chris McCandless and Gene Rosellinni in chapter 8. The two men are similar in a variety of ways. 

Both McCandless and Rosellini came from wealthy, privileged families. Both men also received college degrees and maintained high grade point averages. Both men, by all accounts, were also well liked by people around them.  

His real name was Gene Rosellini. He was the eldest stepson of Victor Rosellini, a wealthy Seattle restaurateur, and cousin of Albert Rosellini, the immensely popular governor of Washington State from 1957 to 1965. As a young man Gene had been a good athlete and a brilliant student. He read obsessively, practiced yoga, became expert at the martial arts. He sustained a perfect 4.0 grade-point average through high school and college.

Both McCandless and Rosellini went out "into the wild" sections of Alaska in search of solitude and perhaps answers.  

The major difference between Chris and Gene is in their motivation to seek out adventure and solitude in Alaska.  McCandless seems to be searching for some kind of spiritual peace. Rosellini, on the other hand, went out to the Alaskan wilderness in order to test a theory of his.  

He wondered whether humans could live as our forebears had when mammoths and saber-toothed tigers roamed the land or whether our species had moved too far from its roots to survive without gunpowder, steel, and other artifacts of civilization. With the obsessive attention to detail that characterized his brand of dogged genius, Rosellini purged his life of all but the most primitive tools, which he fashioned from native materials with his own hands.

Rosellini worked at his life purging theory for 30 years, and came to the conclusion that it is not possible for humans to live completely off of the land.

 I learned that it is not possible for human beings as we know them to live off the land.

Perhaps because of his failure, Rosellini committed suicide by stabbing himself with a knife. That is also a major difference between him and McCandless. McCandless died of natural causes after succumbing to starvation.   

Further Reading:
check Approved by eNotes Editorial
sullymonster eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2005

write1,773 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Business

Both men came from financially secure positions and both turned their back on those positions and on society in order to go in search of a connection with nature.  They both were filled with a belief in their ability to succeed "in the wild".  However, Rosellini wanted to try to prove he could live independently, without modern resources.  Mccandless wanted to have physical, mental and spiritual growth as a result of a communion with nature.  Also, Rosellini died as a result of suicide, presumable from the failure of his dreams.  Mccandless died as a result of injury and extreme weather conditions.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

kandi125 | Student


1. Both Gene Rosellini and Chris Mccandless were athletic in their youth and were considered brilliant, intelligent scholars. 2. Both of them came from wealthy families. 3. They donated to charities and left behind the comfort of money and modern conveniences to live and experience nature. 4. After venturing into the wild, they started going by assumed names they had given themselves. 5. They died in the wild.


1. Rosellini went into the wild to live a primitive lifestyle away from modern technology whereas Mccandless went into the wild to deepen his spirituality. 

2. Rosellini's death was self-inflicted, but Mccandless's death was naturally caused by weather conditions in the environment. 

3. Rosellini committed suicide after he believed he failed at living in nature without modern technology. Mccandless, however, died from starvation and harsh weather conditions in nature. 

4. Rosellini is considered a hippie because he chose to live without modern conveniences and rely on nature. Mccandless, however, would be considered a soul-searcher as he wanted to gain spiritual growth from the experience.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

Unlock This Answer Now