The Liars' Club

by Mary Karr
Start Free Trial

In the beginning of chapter one of The Liar's Club, why does Mary Karr begin with that incident?

Mary Karr begins with the story of her mother because it highlights the complexity of her relationship with her mother, and provides a sense of continuity for the reader. The fire also has symbolic significance; it is an event that defines Mary's thoughts about her mother.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Throughout this memoir of her Texas childhood, Mary Kerr revisits her relationship with both her parents. From her adult perspective, she struggles to understand them as people and not just as parents. Her relationship with her mother is particularly problematic as it typically is the most nurturing relationship a child...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

Throughout this memoir of her Texas childhood, Mary Kerr revisits her relationship with both her parents. From her adult perspective, she struggles to understand them as people and not just as parents. Her relationship with her mother is particularly problematic as it typically is the most nurturing relationship a child will have. The recurring sense of betrayal and abandonment that Mary continues to experience is a theme to which she insists the reader return alongside her.

Although the young Mary had ideas that her mother was different than other mothers, she lacked the knowledge and vocabulary to identify comprehend her mother's difference. On the occasion of the fire, she had an epiphany. The violence of her mother's action, the presence and judgment of the doctor, and the removal of her mother from their home combined to provide a sudden, clear message: her mother was Nervous; things were Not Right.

Karr begins the book with this particular story because it was such a clear road mark on her journey to understanding her childhood.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Mary Karr's poignant and disturbing memoir The Liars' Club starts with an incident that occurred when she was seven. On that night, Karr's mother set a fire to burn the children's possessions in the backyard when Karr's father was at work, and Karr's family doctor investigates her to see if she's been physically harmed. The incident is important in the circular narrative Karr writes about her troubled childhood because it marks the beginning of her constant vigilance to watch for events in her house that she calls "Not Right" (page 9).

Karr writes poetically of that night:

"On the night the sheriff came to our house and Mother was adjudged more or less permanently Nervous, I didn't yet understand the word. I had only a vague tight panic in the pit of my stomach, the one you get when your parents are nowhere in sight and probably don't even know who has a hold of you or where you'll wind up spending the night" (page 7).

Karr's mother is hospitalized for being psychiatrically unsound, and her father is not around. Karr is left on her own with her sister, and it's clear that no one is really taking care of her. 

Karr knows from that point on that her life is going to be chaotic and that her neighbors know that her family cannot take care of her. She writes, "I did know from that night forward that things in my house were Not Right" (page 9). She translates this sense of her house not being right into her sense that she isn't right. "The fact that my house was Not Right metastasized into the notion that I myself was somehow Night Right, or that my survival in that world depended on my constant vigilance against various forms of Non-Rightness" (page 10). Her use of the word "metastasized" is poetically apt, as her town has a chemical plant and oil refinery that cause many people to have cancer. For Karr, the cancer is the dysfunction in her family, and the incident that begins the book establishes her family's broken dynamic that she will explore in the rest of the book. 

 

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team