Are beggars a nuisance in our society?Are beggars are a nuisance in our society? 

8 Answers | Add Yours

litteacher8's profile pic

litteacher8 | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

The way the poor are treated in our society is the nuisance. A large percentage of the homeless are mentally ill, many of those veterans. Our system fails them. We ship them off to prison when they act out, then release them after they've been medicated for awhile with a couple of weeks of pills. Small wonder they end up back on the streets and the cycle starts all over again. The rest of the homeless population is mostly made up of drug users and alcoholics, who also get short-term treatment before returning to the streets. Before we address the problem of homelessness, we need to address these problems.
besure77's profile pic

besure77 | Middle School Teacher | (Level 1) Senior Educator

Posted on

Beggars are a result of a failure of some kind, whether it be a failure on the part of the individual or a failure due to society. There are many reasons why people become beggars. They may have been forced out into the street and have no other choice. Perhaps they have psychological issues and can't help it. Whatever the reason, there are numerous shelters that people like this can go for help.

morrol's profile pic

morrol | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Associate Educator

Posted on

I am surprised by the amount of fear associated with the homeless in this thread. Any one of us has the potential (especially in this economic climate) to end up homeless. I think we all have a responsibility as human beings to show compassion to others, especially toward those in need. 

As far as the amount of homeless fluctuating by season goes, I live in a major city, and the quantity of homeless people seems consistent to me. In your area a fluctuation may be caused by the amount of support from local charities, or the highs and lows of personal mental illness. Regardless, any homelessness should not be seen as a nuisance, it should be seen as a reminder of what we are not doing right as a society.

jennyrocks's profile pic

Jen Sambdman | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Assistant Educator

Posted on

I can't say they are a nuisance because they are doing what they feel they need to do. You can make the active decision to walk past them and ignore them, or give them some change. It is just like a street vendor or performer - ignore, or engage - up to you. There are a lot of them in the downtown areas of lager cities, but that is where more people are so they can get more money to survive. A lot of homeless people are mentally ill and don't understand beyond the need of money to survive. Some beggars are everyday people looking for a quick, tax-free buck. A beggar will generally ask you for spare change, but they don't chase you down and demand money or food. I just see it as someone asking you if you have the time. You can either keep walking as if you didn't hear him/her ask, lie and say you don't have a watch, or tell them the time.

alohaspirit's profile pic

alohaspirit | Middle School Teacher | (Level 2) Assistant Educator

Posted on

Yes I agree with #2, it is a result of failure.  When our homeless rate goes up in our country it should be a reflection of our government, and the blame should be on the lack of social programs to help these individuals.  We need better education with more support for the lower income areas, since those areas tend to have more of a higher drop out rate.  Also we need to focus on creating more jobs for all types of education levels, not everyone is going to go to college and get a four year degree, and many of my friends are still having a tough time getting jobs even after getting a degree.  We need to have better social programs like the welfare system that doesnt enable people to take advantage of it, but to work for it and improve their life skills. 

morrol's profile pic

morrol | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Associate Educator

Posted on

Rather than being a nuisance on society, beggars are a result of a failure in the structure of our society. Poverty is a direct result of a lack of education. America has a poorly funded education system. Given the challenges of competing in a global job market with a poorly funded education system, it is not surprising that some people do end up begging. Another reason for the existence of beggars is a stigma about mental illness. Many people on the street suffer from mental illness that is not always covered by insurance, or that they (especially if they are ex-military) will not get treatment for because of the social stigma. Beggars are not a nuisance in our society, but rather a reminder of our own failures.

gdill's profile pic

gdill | College Teacher | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

In today's economy, how can the argument "poverty is a direct result of education" hold water?  I would guess there are some highly educated individuals begging for resources.  In addition, there are many educational institutions that are literally giving away money to go to vocational school.  Have people become snobby about the type of job they will take?  How do we explain the increased number of beggars during the holiday season?  Where are they in the summer? 

We’ve answered 318,915 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question