What was the basic difference between the economy of the North and the economy of the South?

Expert Answers info

Jonathan Beutlich eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2014

write5,717 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, Science, and History

I am going to assume that this question is asking about the differences in the economies of the northern and southern United States during the Civil War. Prior to the Civil War, the South was the big money maker for the United States in terms of exports. That main export was cotton, and by 1840 it was worth more than all of our other exports combined. Unfortunately, the South lacked in other areas. The South had minimal manufacturing capability, about 29 percent of the railroad tracks, and only 13 percent of the nation's banks. Additionally, most of the South's economy was tightly tied to slavery. This contrasted with the North's "free market" approach. Coinciding with this economic model was the fact that the North's economy was focused on the commercial and manufacturing side of things. As the Industrial Revolution gained momentum, the North's economy boomed as they could produce more textiles, guns, etc. than the South, and the North could produce it faster. These basic differences ended up having a huge impact on the Civil War.

The Union's industrial and economic capacity soared during the war as the North continued its rapid industrialization to suppress the rebellion. In the South, a smaller industrial base, fewer rail lines, and an agricultural economy based upon slave labor made mobilization of resources more difficult. As the war dragged on, the Union's advantages in factories, railroads, and manpower put the Confederacy at a great disadvantage.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

pohnpei397 eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write35,413 answers

starTop subjects are History, Literature, and Social Sciences

There are two major differences between the economies of the North and the South during the time before the Civil War. The North had a more diversified economy based on free labor.  The South had an agrarian economy based on slave labor.

The most famous difference between the economies of the two regions was the difference between free labor and slave labor. Slavery had been legal in the North early in the history of the United States, but it was soon banned. By contrast, slavery remained legal in the South until the end of the Civil War. In the South slavery remained a pillar of the economy.  In 1860, most of the Confederate states had populations that were at least 40% African American.  This was a major difference between the two regions’ economies.

The other difference is less well-known but is perhaps just as important.  This is the difference between an agrarian economy and a diversified economy. The South’s economy was based mainly on the production of cotton for export.  There was very little manufacturing.  By contrast, the North’s economy had a great deal of manufacturing and relatively less farming.  The farming that did go on in the North (and there was a great deal of it) was generally concerned with producing food for domestic markets. 

In these ways, there were two very important differences between the economies of the North and South before the Civil War.

the-excellentclare | Student

In addition to the engrained ideological and societal differences that plagued the North and the South, the two regions also shared major economic differences. The key difference was the South’s dependence on an agricultural based economy driven by slave labor and the North’s dependence on a commercial and manufacturing economy driven by free labor.

As the northern states began to shun slavery from the late 1700s and the early 1800s, the economy also started shifting from agriculture to manufacturing buoyed by European immigration into America, and more specifically into the northern states. European immigrants were more attracted to the free northern states rather than the slavery-dependent southern states, with only one in eight immigrants moving to the South. Most of these immigrants moved into urban areas, providing labor and instigating the growth and success of machine-tool, food-processing, railroad equipment and farm-machinery factories among others. Contrary, the southern states continued to rely on a slavery-driven, agricultural economy which was buoyed by the profitability of cotton. The South did not need to embrace industrial development, the slave economy was extremely profitable and cotton prices were historically high in the early 1800s leaving the South tremendously wealthy.

In essence, the basic economic difference between the South and the North was built on each region’s reliance on the “slave labor” and “free market” economic structures respectively.

scotty3097 | Student

Essentially, the most basic difference between the Northern and Southern economy was in labor and production.

The North had a more diversified economy based on manufacturing a variety of products. In the years leading to the Civil War, the North had begun to feel the effects of the Industrial Revolution. Although much of the region had been industrialized, agriculture remained important. In comparison, the South's economy was largely based in agriculture, specifically cotton. Cotton was an vital cash crop that was produced, for the most part, in the South. However, it was rarely, if ever, manufactured there.

In terms of labor, there was a clear distinction between the North and South: slavery. The North allowed slaves in the early history of the United States, however it was abolished completely by 1804. The North then worked with free labor, meaning that employees had the freedom in choosing positions and reaching success. Conversely, the South worked off slave labor. Slave masters did have to buy their slaves (they were expensive) but they did not have to pay slaves.

Ask a Question