illustrated profile of a woman's head with cracks running through it set against a chrysanthemum background

The Chrysanthemums

by John Steinbeck
Start Free Trial

Based on her reactions to both the fix-it man and her husband Henry, how do you think Elisa wants to be viewed by others in "The Chrysanthemums"? What do you think is Elisa's ideal conception of femininity?

Elisa wishes to be seen as soft and feminine by others in "The Chrysanthemums." Her conception of femininity is complex, and she believes that being feminine means to be both alluring and strong. Her husband is unable to see past Elisa's hard features, preventing him from acknowledging her femininity.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

When we first meet Elisa, she is working in her garden and tending to her chrysanthemums. It's important to note her physical appearance here. She has a "lean and strong" face which is mostly covered with a man's black hat. Her hands are covered in "heavy leather gloves" and her...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

When we first meet Elisa, she is working in her garden and tending to her chrysanthemums. It's important to note her physical appearance here. She has a "lean and strong" face which is mostly covered with a man's black hat. Her hands are covered in "heavy leather gloves" and her figure appears "blocked." She wears a printed dress, but it is almost completely covered with an apron that holds her tools. Elisa's feminine qualities are all but buried under her clothing.

Yet when the tinker appears, Elisa begins to uncover some of her more feminine qualities. She takes off those heavy gloves that cover her hands and touches her hair. She engages with him as an equal, transacting business and noting that she "could show [him] what a woman might do," a sexually suggestive phrase that connotes both her confidence and her spirit of adventure. Although she is dismissed, Elisa shares her dreams with this stranger, telling him that she would love to live a different life out under the stars. She wishes "women could do such things." And as she looks at him, her breast "swell[s] passionately."

To prepare for the evening with her husband, Elisa puts on her prettiest underclothes and "the dress which was the symbol of her prettiness." She carefully styles her hair and applies her make-up. When her husband sees her, he tells her that she looks "different, strong and happy." Elisa questions his usage of the word "strong," and he clarifies that she looks "strong enough to break a calf over [her] knee," which catches Elisa by surprise as his view of her conflicts with the softer image of femininity she has tried to craft for this evening. At dinner when she asks about going with him to see a fight, her husband tells her that she wouldn't like it.

In this setting, Elisa's feminine strength is nearly invisible. Her softer features are covered up in her farm work and underappreciated by her husband. This sense of invisibility extends to Elisa's own dreams, which men constantly remind her that she isn't entitled to. Elisa wants to be recognized as a complete personone who is both beautiful and strong; one who is both hard-working and full of dreams; one who is both a caretaker and a sexual being. That is her definition of femininity.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team