Compare and contrast Abraham Lincoln's First and Second Inaugurals, including a discussion of how his views changed. 

Expert Answers
thanatassa eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The main difference between the First and Second Inaugural Address of Abraham Lincoln was the different contexts in which they were given. In the First Inaugural, Lincoln was in a precarious position. He had received less than 40 percent of the popular vote, and the nation was divided, with 7 states having seceded and the country on the verge of civil war. In this context, Lincoln's focus was not so much on slavery per se, but on national unity and the mandates of the Constitution with respect to the relationship of state and federal governments. The tone of the address is legalistic, focused on specific details of the rule of law, including reassuring southerners that he did not see the Constitution as justifying federal interference in internal arrangements of the Southern states (i.e. slavery) and that he would enforce the Fugitive Slave Act. Although Lincoln was personally opposed to slavery, he saw his position as President as committed above all to the enforcement of the rule of law and his priority as national unity.

In his Second Inaugural Address, the North had almost won the Civil War, and Lincoln's concerns were quite different. No longer needing to accept slavery as the price of national unity, he was focused on making the wartime Emancipation Proclamation the grounds of permanent abolition of slavery. His next major concern was reconciliation, as exemplified in his phrase "with malice toward none; with charity for all." His second speech is much less legalistic and contains fewer specific details, but has a more idealistic moral tone.

jameadows eNotes educator| Certified Educator

In Lincoln's first inaugural address, delivered in March of 1861, he sought to reassure the southern states that he had no intention of interfering with slavery where it existed. He defended the sanctity of the union and stated that no one state could decide to leave the union. While he sought to avoid bloodshed, he stated that he would consider the act of leaving the union an insurrection. At the end of the speech, he again called for the states to be friends and called on "the better angels of our nature." 

By Lincoln's second inaugural address, delivered in March of 1865, the country had long been embroiled in the Civil War, and he stated that there was less need for a long address than there had been in his first inauguration. His second inaugural address was much shorter than the first, and, in it, he admitted the ties between the north and south that he had hoped would stay firm had been broken. He then discussed slavery directly and stated that God "now wills to remove" the institution of slavery. While he sought to protect slavery in his first address, he came to believe that God was on the side of the Union in abolishing slavery. However, as in his first address, he hoped for continued bonds between the different parts of the union and ended his address with a call for "malice toward none, with charity for all." Many historians believe this was a call for reabsorbing the Confederacy into the Union with leniency—a task that fell to Lincoln's successors after his assassination in 1865.