Analyse friendship between Sue and Johnsy."The Last Leaf" by O.Henry

1 Answer | Add Yours

mwestwood's profile pic

mwestwood | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

In O. Henry's poignant story in which two young aspiring artists become "congenial" enough to find a studio apartment together in Greenwich Village, Maine-born Sue worries about her Californian friend, Johanna, whom she calls Johnsy.  For, Johnsy has contracted pneumonia in the cold November of New York.  Having called a doctor to their studio, Sue learns from him that Johnsy has only a slim chance of living because she has lost her will to live.  He tells Sue that she must get Johnsy interested in something that will inspire her to get well.

Now, Sue is a true friend who dearly loves Johnsy.  She tries to motivate Johnsy by humming and being cheerful as she sits by her friend drawing.  But, when she realizes the Johnsy has counted the leaves that have fallen from a vine, she "looks solicitously out of the window."  Calling her friend "dear," Sue asks Johnsy what she counts.  When Johnsy tells her that with the fall of the last leaf from the vine she must go, too.  Sue acts scornful of "such nonsense"; speaking positively, she tells Johnsy that her thoughts about death are "naughty."  For, says Sue, who lies in order to convince Johnsy, the doctor has said that her chances of getting well were "ten to one."

Sue pretends that the situation with Johnsy is not of the magnitude that it is; in her love and hope, she acts as though Johnsy will soon be well.  However, she is truly worried.  So, she begs Johnsy to close her eyes because she needs the light in order to continue her drawings.  Johnsy agrees, but she tells Sue to hurry as she wants to go down like the last leaf. she goes to Mr. Behrman, informing him of the gravity of Johnsy's condition, hoping there is something he can do. Angered that Johnsy is ill,  Behrman complains, then, comes to pose, Sue takes him outside to look at the barren vine with one last leaf. 

So greatly concerned is Sue about her friend that she effects the change in Johnsy's psyche that causes her to become well. Sue's determination to do what she can for her friend saves Johnsy's life.  There is no doubt that Sue loves Johnsy as she has thought about what the doctor has told her and done everything she can to save Johnsy, even convincing Behrman enough that he paints the last leaf onto the glass of the window outside.

We’ve answered 318,961 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question