Why is Charles Olson's poem "The Kingfishers" considered an experiment in both language and in visual effect on the page?

1 Answer

vangoghfan's profile pic

vangoghfan | College Teacher | (Level 2) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

Since Olson’s poem is famously difficult and puzzling, and since I claim no great knowledge of the work, I thought it might be helpful to you if I simply reported what a few students of the poem have said about its language and visual design.

Charles Bernstein, for instance, writes that a

stirring, iconic voice rises up in this poem, one phrase tumbling upon the next, hectoring, charged, bursting through the dead silence and complacency often associated with [a] proto Cold War moment in U.S. history.

Bernstein thinks that the language of the poem challenges the conformist attitudes of the time. According to Bernstein,

The poem is a bracing test of nonlinear reading: because it quickly loses the reader trying diligently to “follow,”

so that its language demands multiple re-readings that never resolve into absolute clarity, at least in Bernstein’s view.

Thomas F. Merrill notes that the poem has been read both as a polemic (against the kind of poetry written by T. S. Eliot) and as a parody (also of Eliot’s verse), although Merrill himself suggests that both of these approaches to the language of the poem are inadequate. Merrill himself, however, offers such a very detailed reading of the poem that it would be difficult to summarize it here.

Daniel Belgrad, who considers “The Kingfishers” to be a “dialogic poem,” argues that the work is a

chain of associations that progresses into the past. The narrator thinks back after a moment of awakening from a troubled night.

Stephen Fredman notes that the poem

consists of many short poetic units, whose continuity with one another can be hard to detect. (http://tinyurl.com/3vvpsy4
[Open in new window])

Meanwhile, Edward Halsey Foster suggests that the poem is indebted, in its shapes, both to ideograms and to the process of making collages,

which bring seemingly unrelated material into a new resolution.  http://tinyurl.com/3hxwbhb
[Open in new window]