After arriving at Buna, a distant relative asks Elie and his father for news of his family. What is Elie's reply? Why does he say this?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Shortly after arriving at Buna, Elie is introduced to one of his relatives named Stein, who inquires about his family. Stein tells Elie that he received news that a transport had arrived from his region and immediately came to search for him. Stein then asks Elie if he had heard...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

Shortly after arriving at Buna, Elie is introduced to one of his relatives named Stein, who inquires about his family. Stein tells Elie that he received news that a transport had arrived from his region and immediately came to search for him. Stein then asks Elie if he had heard anything about his wife, Reizel, and his two small boys from Antwerp. Elie mentions that he had not heard anything about Stein's family but proceeds to tell his relative that Reizel and his boys are alive and well. Elie lies to Stein about Reizel and his two boys because he realizes the importance of hope. Elie understands that hope in a better future and reuniting with one's family is the most significant motivating factor to continue living and survive the horrific ordeal. Elie believes that lying to Stein about his family being alive will give him the motivation to persevere and survive the Holocaust. Stein continues to regularly visit Elie and his father and shares his food rations with them until he learns the real news regarding the tragic fate of his family.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

When Elie and his father arrive at their new camp, they are greeted by Stein from Antwerp, a distant relative. Stein asks Elie if he has any news about Stein's family. In reality, Elie has no information about Stein's family; however, he lies and tells Stein that his family is alive and doing well. Why does he do this? At this point, Elie has realized the role of hope in survival. He knows that if he gives Stein hope, he will increase Stein's chances of making it through the concentration camp. Elie has little materially to offer, but this is something he can give.

Unfortunately, the "gift" is short-lived. When a transport arrives from Antwerp soon after, Stein learns the actual fate of his family and never visits Elie again.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team