In Act II of The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, how does Brutus convince the conspirators that they should not swear an oath in killing Caesar?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Brutus convinces the conspirators by merely explaining why no oath is necessary or fitting. He reminds them that in killing Caesar their motives are strong and honorable. Brutus speaks of "the sufferance of our souls" under Caesar's tyranny. He alludes to the "fire" in the conspirators, strong enough to rally their countrymen to...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

Brutus convinces the conspirators by merely explaining why no oath is necessary or fitting. He reminds them that in killing Caesar their motives are strong and honorable. Brutus speaks of "the sufferance of our souls" under Caesar's tyranny. He alludes to the "fire" in the conspirators, strong enough to rally their countrymen to the cause of freedom.  Brutus explains that those men who swear oaths are contemptible, cowardly and deceitful. Oaths are necessary only for bad men with bad causes. Brutus implores them not to "stain" the goodness of what they are about to do.

The conspirators, especially Cassius whose idea it was to take an oath, defer to Brutus out of their respect for him--and their need for him to participate in the conspiracy because he is so highly regarded by the Roman people. Before the issue of the oath arises, Cassius has pointed out to Brutus that "[there is] no man here but honors you."

There is irony in Brutus's words to the conspirators. What they are about to do could well be considered contemptible and cowardly. They are certainly acting in a deceitful manner, slinking about in the dark and plotting in secret. By refusing to swear an oath, Brutus is attempting to make their assassination of Caesar seem like a noble deed so that he can live with himself for being a part of it.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team