Assess the function of Mercutio in the play. Why is he so important to the play and to the development of its themes?I'm trying to think about this, but I can't seem to delve as deep in analysis as...

Assess the function of Mercutio in the play. Why is he so important to the play and to the development of its themes?

I'm trying to think about this, but I can't seem to delve as deep in analysis as my teacher would like. What I mostly have so far is that he seems lighthearted, a good friend, and a man of many words.

Currently, it's rather hard for me to do anything beyond a C (sometimes B) on essays and it's really frustrating. Can someone please help me on this, hopefully before the end of tomorrow?

Asked on by ronnicus

3 Answers | Add Yours

robertwilliam's profile pic

robertwilliam | College Teacher | (Level 2) Senior Educator

Posted on

The points you make are all valid. But I don't think you're reading the question carefully enough (and believe me, reading the question well is the hallmark of the A grade student!). You're being asked about the "function" of Mercutio, not his character. What that means is that you need to consider Shakespeare's play as a machine which Shakespeare fixed together piece by piece. Why put Mercutio in as a character? What does he add to the play?

So you're certainly right that he is a loyal friend (some people even argue that he is in love with Romeo, because he's so heavily against Romeo being in love with Rosaline) and that he's light-hearted. You're certainly right that he has a way with words and is an amazing poet. But what job does he do? What does he add to the play?

Well, first, I'd argue that he is a properly cynical voice about love. He argues, in the Queen Mab speech and the scene around it, that love is a dream, and that a dream is nothing - just spurious fantasy:

True, I talk of dreams;
Which are the children of an idle brain,
Begot of nothing but vain fantasy;
Which is as thin of substance as the air,
And more inconstant than the wind, who wooes
Even now the frozen bosom of the north
And, being anger'd, puffs away from thence,
Turning his face to the dew-dropping south.

Love is "inconstant". Like Romeo, love turns from the north to the south. It changes. And Mercutio seems to hate it - he's one of the few voices in the play to speak out against love, and for friendship. He never finds out that Romeo is in love with Juliet (making his death strangely ironic as, when he calls for a plague on both houses, he thinks he is cursing Tybalt and Romeo, when in fact, he is cursing Juliet and Romeo too).

He adds a spirit of high-jinks in his scene with the Nurse, singing, teasing her, and showing us what Romeo was like before he was lovesick. He shows us Romeo's history. But he also supplies a vein of sexual, bawdy comedy which disappears from the play when he dies. And I'd say that's his key function. He makes the first half of the play seem like a comedy. And the minute he disappears from it, the play twists into tragedy. He's the last character you'd expect to end up dead. His function is, through his death, to twist the play into tragedy after his death.

See what I mean? It's not his character, and what he's like. It's why write a character like that in the play at all?

Hope it helps!

madelynfair's profile pic

madelynfair | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Adjunct Educator

Posted on

A great question. Ostensibly, Mercutio is a side character in a tragicomic play about two lovers who are the protagonists, so at first glance, he may seem only like a sideliner and not that important. But in literature, great literature especially, every character counts. So if you want to move beyond a "C" in your literary analysis, treat everything in works by greats such as Shakespeare as seriously symbolic.

So, let's examine Mercutio carefully in terms of function and personality. You're already doing a good job of characterizing his personality. "Light-hearted" is a characteristic you can easily prove. Search acts one through three for instances of his joking around, particularly his bawdy ones, and you'll have plenty of evidence of his ability to get a crowd laughing.

You say he is a "good friend." This is an evaluative judgment (any time you put "good" or a criterion-based adjective, you're evaluating), so you need to back this up. What makes a good friend? Make a list of good qualities in a friend, and then see if Mercutio measures up. Is a good friend loyal? Thoughtful? Compassionate? (Rate Mercutio in each of these areas in how he treats Romeo.). I will challenge you to think about the kind of friend he is and come up with a more specific adjective than "good," because "good" is a bit too general for a complicated guy such as Mercutio. Some would argue that his kind of "good" does Romeo no good! But there are many ways to argue this.

You say "a man of many words." True, he is that, but what kind of words? Do you mean talkative only, or a man who says a lot of a certain kind of statement? Take a moment to examine the Queen Mab speech (act one, scene four), and really study the images that Mercutio raises. Are they pleasant, interesting, exciting, gruesome images -- what kind? I would use that speech to characterize the kind of talking Mercutio does.

Now on to function. This is using the same strategies we've just been using, but asking you to think more globally about Mercutio's role in the play. Find two to three key decisions that he makes (hint: act one, scene four, he gives advice to Romeo in the line, "Nay, gentle Romeo...," and that qualifies as a decision. Then, in act three, scene one, he makes a life-changing decision.

Now ask yourself: how do Mercutio's key decisions affect the course of the entire play?

Finally, think of the concept of friendship as a concept that weaves through the whole play. Benvolio, Mercutio, the Nurse, and the Friar can all be counted as friends to the main characters, Romeo and Juliet. In terms of being "good friends," who do you find to be the best, and why?

Therefore, when you answer a question such as the one you posed, you can answer it by characterizing Mercutio (listing his most important qualities in terms of quality or goodness), by listing his key decisions that affect the plot, and by evaluating him in light of his role as friend (when friendship is a concept that is dealt with again and again).

Note the distinction between concept and theme: a concept is an idea, a topic, such as "friendship," "love," or "loyalty." To write a thesis statement about a theme, you need to make a claim, as in, "Mercutio is a ____ type of friend and in this play compares to other friends in the following way..." You want to make an overall statement about how an idea -- a theme -- gets played out via characters' choices and roles.

Good luck!

 

ronnicus's profile pic

ronnicus | Student, Grade 9 | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

Thanks guys, this will help a lot. Your comments have given me some good ideas on how to go about writing my essay.

We’ve answered 318,930 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question