4) Can you trace the expansion of presidential power throughout American history? What are the formal powers of the president and how have presidents expanded their power beyond the Constitution?...

4) Can you trace the expansion of presidential power throughout American history? What are the formal powers of the president and how have presidents expanded their power beyond the Constitution? How does a president utilize informal powers?

Expert Answers
pohnpei397 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The general trend in presidential power over the course of American history has been upward.  Presidents have gained power over time.  However, the trend has not been continuous.  Instead, there have been times when presidential power has declined.  The increase in presidential power has come in both formal and informal types of power.

Early in our nation’s history, the presidency (and indeed the entire national government) was not very strong.  Congress was generally the strongest branch of the federal government but the government was not very expansive compared to its current status.  There were times when presidents’ powers increased.  This was especially true in time of war.  For example, Abraham Lincoln exercised rather significant powers during his time in office.

From the beginning of the 20th century on, the power of the presidency has grown fairly consistently.  This has happened for two reasons.  First, presidential powers have grown during times of war.  This was seen most clearly in World War II and then in the early stages of the War on Terror.  Second, there has been a major expansion of the federal government, thus giving the president power over more areas of American life.  Expansion of the government happened, for example, during the Progressive Era, the New Deal, and the Great Society.  In these ways, presidents have gained more power over time.

Some of this power has been formal.  This has come with the expansion of the federal executive branch.  As the executive branch has gotten so much bigger, presidents have been able to appoint more officials.  They have also presided over an executive branch that reaches into more and more aspects of our lives.  The recent creation of “Obamacare” is an example of this.

However, the expanded power of the president has also been informal.  This has come largely through the mass media.  It has been said that the presidential power is the power to persuade.  With the rise of mass media, presidents have been able to appeal directly to the people.  This was done, for example, by Franklin D. Roosevelt through his “fireside chats.”  Today, it happens when all of the networks break away from their regular programming to broadcast presidential speeches.  The media increases the president’s power to persuade (if the president has the skills and popularity needed to persuade people).

So, presidential power has generally increased over time.  The increase has been in both formal and informal power.  It has come about because of crises like wars, changes in technology, and changes in our attitudes towards government.

amysor | Student

Since 1776, when America became a country, presidential powers have shifted a lot. At first, with the Articles of Confederation, since it focused on state's rights, the president had little power in making choices. This was fixed with the constitution and balance of powers. Checks and balances help keep the three branches of government, executive, legislative, and judicial from becoming too powerful. Over time, some presidents have gone on to corrupt their power. John Adams and his Midnight Judges, appointing new judges on his last day of office. This was seen as corrupt, but it wasn't specified he could not do so, so in Marbury v. Madison, judicial review was established.President Andrew Jackson traded jobs for political favors, which was known as the spoils system. It was a system of corruption that allowed his supporters to get government position. Today, this is not legal. Even Honest Abe (Abraham Lincoln) corrupted his power when he suspended the writ of habeas corpus, which was a protection against proper imprisonment. With each event, limitations of a president's power become more clear. Today, a president has much less power than before, but still has enough power to be a strong leader and make decisions. 

user5862657 | Student

Thanks amysor, although I did not mark yours as best answer, I can tell why you are a Valedictorian,  You have great summarizing skills, which I lack of and you are going to succeed in whatever your pursue.  Congratulations.  Keep in touch.  I love to make a lot of questions about Government and Politics and your post, although a little bit short for what I need, are very easy to understand and at the same time, with  very hight level for being a Grade 10 Student!