Ordeal by Innocence ★½ 1984 (PG-13) Sutherland is an amateur sleuth in 1950s England convinced he has proof that a convicted murderer is innocent, but no one wishes to reopen the case. Bigname cast is essentially wasted. Based on an Agatha Christie story. 91m/C VHS. Donald Sutherland, Christopher Plummer, Faye Dunaway, Sarah Miles, Ian McShane, Diana Quick, Annette Crosbie, Michael Elphick; Director: Desmond Davis; Writer: Billy Williams; Cameo: Pino Donaggio.