Home > Twilight Summary & Study Guide > Twilight Group > Discussion Board

i agree to talk to any adults about it

My mother isn't allowing my younger sister to read it, and I would agree with her. There are very adult situations in it, and some are inappropriate, like the birth scene. I wouldn't suggest her reading it until she is 11 or 12. 

I read this book when I was 11, and it wasn't really bad. I mean, there was sex in some parts, and the birth scene was a little scary, but it was nothing I couldn't handle. But, then again, that's just me personally. Your sis is 12, so I imagine she can handle it. She's in 6th or 7th grade, so she will be hearing and reading about that kind of thing. It's not really your decision what she reads, so I would talk with your mom and discuss her views on the subject. My mom read the book shortly after I did, and she thought it was very sci-fi, not inappropriate. She is not, however, going to let my 10-year-old sister read it. She's in 4th grade, for one, and she doesn't understand that sort of thing.

Skip the whole first Bella section :D

Just see if she's mature enough to handle it.

Okay i'm 11. I haven't ready braking dawn yet bcuz i'm still on eclispe. But nobodys stopping me from readg braking dawn. my friend told me they explain the sex scene but i havent read it so i dnt kno.

BUt let her read it

Cruel and Unusual Punishment.

After reading Twilight, New Moon and Eclipse - how exactly do you propose to stop her from reading the finale'?

You should just let her read it, a rule of thumb should be if you can get through the first three books understand and comprehend it. Then the 4th book will be fine, 12 is not that young. *and to be frank I thought the sex senes were lame way too pg-13*

Plus i am worried for your safely is you prohibit her from reading the LAST book of the series.

In reply to #8:No there different books. There Is Twilight,New Moon, Eclipse, Breaking Dawn, and word is out that Meyers is making a new one calles "midnight sun".