Study Guide

You Shall Know Them

by Jean Bruller

You Shall Know Them Essay - Critical Essays

Analysis

Vercors addresses the inconclusiveness of the law defining murder as the illegal killing of a human being without in any way defining a human being. His novel does not resolve the problem, but it does alert readers to the generally ignored existence of it, embracing, among other contexts, the questions of euthanasia and cruelty to animals.

The English title is taken from an English version of Matthew 7:16-20 (“You shall know them by their fruits . . .”), a parable likening false prophets and wrongdoers to plants producing bad fruit. The title has to be skewed a bit to reflect the novel, so that the allusion is to the recognition of human beings by specific traits or qualities. Curiously, the novel’s courtroom debate includes an anthropological acceptance of Piltdown Man, which was exposed as a hoax in the year following the novel’s publication—the year, in fact, during which the English translation was published. This fact lends irony, unintended or otherwise, to the English title, a hoaxer being akin to a false prophet.

Vercors’ title is, literally, “the denatured animals.” Animals, the judge in the story surmises, are at one with nature; they cannot question it. The human being, in questioning nature, becomes separate from it. The human and nature are two: before the schism, animal; after the schism, human or denatured animal. This schisme, or arrachement (wrench, wrenching) is presented in Pierre Teilhard...

(The entire section is 416 words.)