Samuel Hearne Essay - Critical Essays

Hearne, Samuel

Introduction

Samuel Hearne 1745-1792

English-Canadian narrative writer.

Samuel Hearne's reputation rests on A Journey from Prince of Wales's Fort in Hudson's Bay to the Northern Ocean, (1795), which is considered a classic of Canadian-American literature of exploration. Hearne's work, commonly shortened to A Journey to the Northern Ocean, tells of his three attempts from 1769 to 1772 to find the source of copper that Canadian Indians traded for English goods and, more importantly, to locate the fabled Northwest Passage that would enable European ships to travel by water across the American continent en route to Asia. On both counts Hearne's efforts proved futile: the copper mine he located near the Arctic Ocean held only small deposits of the metal, and his journeys laid to rest the myth that a navigable waterway existed that could shorten the distance from Europe to the Pacific Ocean. Nevertheless, Hearne's narrative, filled with details about the life of native peoples and the flora and fauna of the continent, was an immediate popular success throughout Europe and North America. The narrative continues to be read by students of Canadian and Amerindian history and anthropology for some of the earliest firsthand accounts of aboriginal customs and folklore. Students of literature also appreciate Hearne's account for its narrative sophistication in addition to its relatively sympathetic portrayal of the native peoples on whom Hearne relied to complete his journey to the Arctic Ocean.

Biographical Information

Hearne was born in London in 1745, but his mother moved the family to Dorset after the death of his father in 1748. As he showed little interest in school, Hearne was sent to work as a seaman's apprentice around 1756. He served in the British navy during the Seven Years War (1756-63) and in 1766 found employment with the Hudson's Bay Company in British Canada, whaling and trading with the Inuit. In 1769 Hearne received orders to travel to the Arctic Ocean to search for the Northwest Passage and to locate a source of copper. Although Hearne's first two attempts quickly ended in failure, they significantly informed his planning for the third attempt, which was begun in December 1770. Hearne joined a nomadic group of Chipewyan hunters, and eventually reached the shore of the Arctic Ocean in 1771. Upon his return in 1772 he was sent by the Hudson's Bay Company to establish the Cumberland House, the company's first inland post, which he completed in 1774. Two years later he was made governor of Fort Prince of Wales, a position he held until 1782, when French warships, allied with the Americans against British rule, attacked the fort. Hearne was forced to surrender to noted navigator and author Admiral la Pérouse, who initially seized Hearne's manuscript of his narrative, but returned it on condition that Hearne complete and publish the work. Hearne spent the next several years working on the account of his journeys. Retiring from the Hudson's Bay Company in 1786 due to ill health, Hearne returned to his native England, where he died in 1792, one month after selling his narrative.

Major Works

Hearne used the journals he kept from 1769 to 1772 to fashion the narrative of A Journey to the Northern Ocean. Much of the work is concerned with the flora and fauna he encountered on his expeditions. Many of the etchings he made of animals, plants, and landscapes continue to be reproduced today. His descriptions of life among the Chipewyan people who aided him on his third expedition have provided early and valuable firsthand accounts of aboriginal life, social structures, and beliefs. Hearne's story of adventure and hardship focuses largely on his adaptating to the practices of, and accommodating the needs of, his guides. His depiction of the Amerindians with whom he travelled is generally sympathetic, though in his description of the Massacre at Bloody Fall he expresses horror at being powerless to stop his guides from massacring twenty-two defenseless Inuit. Although A Journey to the Northern Ocean failed to completely halt other expeditions in search of the Northwest Passage, its portrait of an explorer willing to adopt strange customs and ways in order to succeed and survive has had an important influence on historical and anthropological studies.

Critical Reception

Journey to the Northern Ocean was an immediate popular success, both in North America and in Europe, where it was soon translated into a half dozen other languages. William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Edgar Allan Poe, and Henry David Thoreau all mentioned Hearne's narrative as an inspiration for their own works. Although the accuracy of his maps has often been questioned, Hearne's presentation of the terrain, plants, and animals, particularly in his etchings, have earned praise from naturalists to this day. Historians and anthropologists have long taken an interest in Hearne's writing for its valuable information on northern aboriginal customs and beliefs. As literature, Hearne's A Journey to the Northern Ocean is almost unanimously praised for its style, a fact made more remarkable considering Hearne's lack of formal education. In recent decades literary criticism has tended to focus on Hearne's character, in particular whether he was “timorous” in his dealings with the Chipewyan people, as John Bartlet Brebner has argued, or progressive in his adoption of Amerindian ways and leadership. Hearne's often quoted and frequently anthologized depiction of the Massacre at Bloody Fall, and his own passivity in retarding the slaughter, is the subject of much scholarly debate. Other literary studies have tended variously to use Hearne's account to discuss European notions of discovery, the explorer's position as a part of a larger European imperial project, and the formation of North American conceptions of nature. A Journey to the Northern Ocean, with its central plot of an Englishman living within a strange civilization as he slowly makes his way across the landscape of the Canadian Northwest Territories, continues to provoke debate among academics and interest among readers.

Principal Works

A Journey from Prince of Wales's Fort in Hudson's Bay to the Northern Ocean [A Journey to the Northern Ocean] (narrative) 1795

Journals of Samuel Hearne and Philip Turner, edited by J. B. Tyrell (journal) 1934

Criticism

I. S. MacLaren (essay date winter 1984)

SOURCE: MacLaren, I. S. “Samuel Hearne and the Landscapes of Discovery.” Canadian Literature 3 (winter 1984): 27-40.

[In the following essay, MacLaren argues that Hearne's depictions of landscapes in A Journey to the Northern Ocean show his own as well as his countrymen's evolving understanding of nature.]

Although the literary merit of Samuel Hearne's A Journey … to the Northern Ocean (1795) has been recognized, and while the narrative has been deemed “one of the most sophisticated early journals and narratives,” a search has not yet been undertaken for demonstrations of this sophistication in either the explorer's writing style or the ways in...

(The entire section is 6616 words.)

Bruce Greenfield (essay date winter 1968-87)

SOURCE: Greenfield, Bruce. “The Idea of Discovery as a Source of Narrative Structure in Samuel Hearne's Journey to the Northern Ocean.Early American Literature 21, no. 3 (winter 1986-87): 189-209.

[In the following essay, Greenfield discusses how the European idea of discovery shaped Hearne's narrative style in Journey to the Northern Ocean.]

Most scholars of the discovery of the Americas have understood that, as Quinn says, “there could be no real discovery of North America unless, and until, there was a written record of that discovery.”1 Among the earliest students of the subject, Richard Hakluyt, the great sixteenth-century editor of...

(The entire section is 9302 words.)

I. S. MacLaren (essay date January 1991)

SOURCE: MacLaren, I. S. “Samuel Hearne's Accounts of the Massacre at Bloody Fall, 17 July 1771.” ARIEL 22, no. 1 (January 1991): 25-51.

[In the following essay, MacLaren points to differences in Hearne's field notes and the subsequently published A Journey to the Northern Ocean to show that the latter is not necessarily an accurate account of the events being depicted.]

In the twentieth century we are continually trying to alter and refine our descriptions of facts, while at the same time trying to stabilize literary texts in “definitive” editions. The description of a fact has no acknowledged literary value and becomes disposable at a...

(The entire section is 11421 words.)

Robin McGrath (essay date 1993)

SOURCE: McGrath, Robin. “Samuel Hearne and the Inuit Oral Tradition.” Studies in Canadian Literature 18, no. 2 (1993): 94-109.

[In the following essay, McGrath compares Hearne's written account of the massacre at Bloody Fall with Inuit oral histories of that and other massacres.]

In recent years, Samuel Hearne's A Journey From Prince of Wales Fort to the Northern Ocean has been the subject of considerable academic disagreement. A. J. M. Smith has called the work “a classic of English prose” (Smith 53), and Maurice Hodgeson has said it exemplifies “the best characteristics in the genre of travel literature” (Hodgeson 40), claims denied by Dermot...

(The entire section is 6220 words.)

Keith Harrison (essay date September-December 1995)

SOURCE: Harrison, Keith. “Samuel Hearne, Matonabbee, and the ‘Esquimaux Girl’: Cultural Subjects, Cultural Objects.” Canadian Review of Comparative Literature 22, nos. 3-4 (September-December 1995): 647-57.

[In the following essay, Harrison analyzes Hearne's changing portrayals of identity and self in Journey to the Northern Ocean.]

The heroizing implicit in the trope of exploration is downplayed, even subverted in Samuel Hearne's A Journey from Prince of Wales's Fort in Hudson's Bay to the Northern Ocean …, a sometimes boring narrative tinged with farce and shaped by anti-climax which often represents the narrator as passive. As Bruce...

(The entire section is 4685 words.)

Kevin D. Hutchings (essay date April 1997)

SOURCE: Hutchings, Kevin D. “Writing Commerce and Cultural Progress in Samuel Hearne's A Journey … to the Northern Ocean.ARIEL 28, no. 2 (April 1997): 49-78.

[In the following essay, Hutchings seeks to provide a middle ground between those scholars who see Hearne's writings as passive and unbiased and those who view the explorer as an imperial colonist, concentrating on Hearne's evolving awareness of differences between English and aboriginal cultures.]

… though it is not to be supposed that the compiler of a general work can be intimately acquainted with every subject of which it may be necessary to treat, yet a very moderate share...

(The entire section is 11857 words.)

Kathleen Venema (essay date 1998)

SOURCE: Venema, Kathleen. “Mapping Culture onto Geography: ‘Distance from the Fort’ in Samuel Hearne's Journal.Studies in Canadian Literature 23, no. 1 (1998): 9-31.

[In the following essay, Venema argues that Hearne's Eurocentric worldview can be found in his narrative accounts of space and his own geographical distance from the Hudson's Bay Company forts.]

On 12 August 1770, likely on the plain west of Dubawnt Lake (Hearne [A Journey …] 95n), a gust of wind smashed Samuel Hearne's quadrant onto stony ground and damaged it beyond repair. Hearne was forced, as a result, to give up his second attempt to reach the mouth of the Coppermine River...

(The entire section is 10013 words.)