The Long Loneliness Essay - Masterplots II: Women’s Literature Series The Long Loneliness Analysis

Dorothy Day

Masterpieces of Women's Literature The Long Loneliness Analysis

The Long Loneliness reinterprets and updates Dorothy Day’s life story as related in the fictionalized work The Eleventh Virgin (1924) and From Union Square to Rome (1938), the first account of her conversion. The Eleventh Virgin, even with its probable embellishment of details, reconstructed dialogues, and name changes, enriches study of Day’s life, revealing her attitudes a few years before her religious conversion. The novel’s authenticity is confirmed by Day’s credo of writing from experience, its obvious parallels to the subsequent autobiographies, and her own remarks to her biographer, William D. Miller. Embarrassed by its mildly racy plot, breathless style, and moral immaturity, Day disavowed the “very bad book,” to the point of buying and destroying copies.

Favoring plot over psychological analysis and a contrived ending over reality, the book makes a bid to rejoin the heroine June (Dorothy Day) and her feckless companion Dick (Lionel Moise). June rejects the traditional domesticity of her mother to relish the excitement of a career and radical activism, while she samples the sexual freedom of “new womanhood.” Disappointed in love and career, in an amazing turnaround, June resolves to marry her unreliable paramour and have babies. Day’s personal agenda at the time is reflected in this jejune ending. The work documents Day’s gender-role discomfort well before her religious conversion, and the unlikely scenario underscores Day’s inability to envision an alternative to traditional female domesticity or its contemporary opposite, new womanhood.

The puzzling title The Eleventh Virgin, may refer to a biblical parable about salvation in which five virgins with oil lamps join a wedding feast and five others, who are unprepared, are turned away. Among neither the saved nor the damned, the solitary eleventh virgin ends her alienation by dreaming of marriage to the unworthy lover and motherhood—unlikely developments, despite her cheery optimism.

From Union Square to Rome revisits many events covered in the fictionalized autobiography. Addressed to Day’s communist brother (although initially published in an obscure Catholic magazine), the narrative links Day’s radical social conscience to her...

(The entire section is 944 words.)