Critical Evaluation

L’Assommoir is the seventh in a series of twenty novels written by Émile Zola about several generations of the Rougon-Macquart family. It is one of the first such generational series and is carefully shaped by the author according to his controversial ideas for a novel that would parallel, he hoped, the objective observation he admired in the natural sciences. His notion was to treat his characters something like guinea pigs in a world that he would create for them. Narrative impartiality and objectivity were paramount.

Not surprisingly, a public that had loved the romantic version of the poor offered them in Victor Hugo’s Les Miserables (1862) was outraged by the squalor that Zola describes in L’Assommoir. The raw language and the clear parallels that the author draws between his characters and barnyard animals disgusted many readers, who found such a depiction threatening to their belief that the human soul raises men and women above the frailties of their bodies. L’Assommoir also indicts readers who imagine the poor are ennobled by horrible living conditions.

Zola defended the book as the first novel about working-class people that does not lie about their daily lives. He claimed that the characters in L’Assommoir are not evil but ignorant and victimized by the crushing work that fills their days. Pointing to the collapse of Gervaise and the others, he described the novel as morality in action, implicitly teaching his readers a lesson in the consequences of alcohol, lethargy, jealousy, and irresponsibility.

Many find the novel quite painful to read, since the downfall of several of its well-meaning characters is relentless and even cruel. The narration and characterization are truly compelling, more like a classic Greek tragedy than a soap opera, and many readers find the experience one they never forget. Gervaise—with her limp, her youthfulness, her determination, her hard work, and her resilience in the face of great odds—wins over most readers, who cheer her success against Virginie and her initial financial good sense. Zola does all that can be expected of an author to offer readers a sympathetic character. This makes her destruction all the more painful. At...

(The entire section is 924 words.)