The Hoosier Schoolmaster Essay - Critical Essays

Edward Eggleston

Critical Evaluation

As one of America’s early literary Realists, Edward Eggleston was part of a movement to counter the excesses of bucolic Romanticism with “truth-telling” about the bleakness of agrarian life, the bitter—and often petty—rivalries of small-town life, and the very real hatreds and resentments found in class conflicts. Influenced by the French critic Hippolyte Adolphe Taine, Eggleston—like such contemporaries as Hamlin Garland and William Dean Howells—followed the dictum “he writes best who writes about what he knows best.” Thus, in THE HOOSIER SCHOOLMASTER, Eggleston based his novel upon the experiences—with which he was intimately familiar—of his brother George, a teacher in his early years and later a noted journalist, biographer, historian, and novelist in his own right. Eggleston also made a special effort, in all of his work, to capture accurately and reflect the peculiar speech and behavior patterns of the people he depicted.

A direct offshoot of this particular version of Realism was Eggleston’s regionalism, for in writing of what he knew best, he wrote of his native Indiana whose residents were called Hoosiers. The Hoosiers who people the novel are dour, small-town folk preoccupied with the facade of respectability. Accordingly, since pauperism is construed as a major social transgression, Pete Jones’s attempt to have the Pearsons declared indigent so that Shocky Thomson could be indentured is a deliberate expression...

(The entire section is 431 words.)