Eugene O'Neill Analysis

Discussion Topics (Masterpieces of American Literature)

In what respects do the family relationships in Long Day’s Journey into Night and other Eugene O’Neill plays mirror those of his early life?

What was the state of the American theater when O’Neill began writing?

How did the Provincetown Players contribute to O’Neill’s success?

Does O’Neill’s Mourning Becomes Electra differ thematically from Aeschylus’s Oresteia (458 b.c.e.)?

What is the significance of the masks in The Great God Brown?

How does the setting of The Iceman Cometh facilitate the realization of the play’s theme?

Plays depend for their success on audiences. Would O’Neill’s long plays have been more effective if he had shortened them substantially?

Eugene O'Neill Other Literary Forms (Critical Edition of Dramatic Literature)

ph_0111200567-Oneill.jpgEugene O’Neill Published by Salem Press, Inc.

Although primarily known for his plays, Eugene O’Neill also wrote poetry and a large amount of correspondence, collected in several volumes and published posthumously. Among these are “The Theatre We Worked For”: The Letters of Eugene O’Neill to Kenneth MacGowan (1982), edited by Jackson R. Bryer and Ruth M. Alvarez and containing an introductory essay by Travis Bogard; “Love and Admiration and Respect”: The O’Neill-Commins Correspondence (1986), edited by Dorothy Commins; and “As Ever, Gene”: The Letters of Eugene O’Neill to George Jean Nathan (1987), edited by Nancy L. Roberts and Arthur W. Roberts. O’Neill’s poems were published in Poems, 1912-1944 (1979) and were edited by Donald Gallup. His unpublished or unfamiliar writings were published in The Unknown O’Neill (1988), edited by Travis Bogard.

Eugene O'Neill Achievements (Critical Edition of Dramatic Literature)

Eugene O’Neill has been called, rightly, the father of modern American drama, not only because he was the first major American playwright but also because of the influence of his work on the development of American theater and on other dramatists. In addition to achieving both popular success and critical acclaim in the United States, O’Neill has achieved an international reputation. Produced throughout the world, his plays are the subject of countless critical books and articles. In many of his plays, O’Neill employed traditional themes such as the quest, while in others he treated subjects that had gone largely unexamined on the American stage, particularly subjects concerning human psychology. Although many of his works are now universally acclaimed, initial critical reaction to the emotional content of some of these plays was mixed. In addition to breaking new ground in theme and subject matter, O’Neill was innovative in his use of technical elements of the theater. He experimented with such devices as masks, “asides,” and even the stage itself as vehicles to further themes. Moreover, in an effort to achieve for the drama the broad temporal spectrum of the novel, he experimented with dramatic time, presenting two of his works in trilogies of nine acts each. Although some of O’Neill’s dramatic and theatrical experiments were less well received than others, his reputation is now secure; his plays continue to be widely produced throughout the world, both on the stage and on film, because they speak to the human experience that is shared by all.

Eugene O'Neill Eugene O’Neill (20th-Century Biographies)

Early Life

Eugene Gladstone O’Neill was born in a Broadway hotel at a corner of Times Square on October 16, 1888. His father, James O’Neill (1846-1920), came to the United States from Ireland when he was ten and established himself as a talented Shakespearean actor, expected to inherit the mantle of Edwin Booth. In 1883, the elder O’Neill opened as the protagonist Edmond Dantès in a dramatization of The Count of Monte-Cristo (1844-1845), by Alexandre Dumas, père. The play proved a spectacular success, and James O’Neill toured with it for the next fifteen years, earning up to forty thousand dollars annually to assuage his incessant fear of poverty. Later, the father came to believe that he had sacrificed his opportunity for greatness upon the altar of materialism. His son took this regret as a cautionary lesson and resolved never to compromise his artistic integrity for money.

Eugene’s mother, Ellen Quinlan O’Neill (1857-1922), was a devout Catholic, educated in a convent in South Bend, Indiana, where she won a medal for her piano-playing but seriously considered becoming a nun. She fell in love with the dashing James O’Neill when his company toured South Bend. She accompanied her husband on his road trips for many years, all the while resenting their nomadic itinerary of frequent one-night stands, hotel rooms, and irregular meals. Eugene, once established as a playwright, developed an emphatic fondness for settled routine and a detestation of trains and hotels.

Ellen O’Neill found an escape from her aversion to theatrical traveling by becoming an increasingly addicted morphine user. She withdrew from many of her child-rearing responsibilities, leaving Eugene to be mothered, during his first seven years, by a Cornish nursemaid, Sarah Sandy, who exposed her charge to sensational horror stories. The elder O’Neill sent his son to Catholic preparatory schools in New York and Connecticut. In 1906, Eugene entered Princeton University, drank heavily, and studied very little; after a brick-throwing episode, he was failed in all of his courses and never returned to the university. For the next two years, he spent most of his time touring Manhattan in the company of his alcoholic older brother, James, Jr. (1878-1923).

On October 2, 1909, Eugene secretly married the non-Catholic Kathleen Jenkins, the beautiful daughter of a once-wealthy New York family. Two weeks later, the bridegroom left her to prospect for gold in Honduras. There he found not shining metal but a severe case of malaria; he was to use his knowledge of the tropical jungle in The Emperor Jones (1920). Even though Kathleen gave birth to a son, Eugene, Jr., on May 5, 1910, O’Neill refused to live with them upon his return, ignoring his firstborn until after the child’s eleventh birthday. On July 10, 1912, Kathleen Jenkins was awarded an interlocutory divorce decree.

The year 1912 proved to be the crucial year of Eugene O’Neill’s life: The nuclear O’Neill family—father, mother, two sons—spent the summer together in O’Neill’s parents’ New London, Connecticut, home, with Eugene writing for the local paper. In December, 1912, he was diagnosed as tubercular; Ellen O’Neill refused to accept the physician’s findings, withdrawing into morphine-induced fantasies. Miserly James O’Neill first placed Eugene in Connecticut’s Fairfield County State Sanatorium, a bleakly depressing charity institution, many of whose patients died. After staying there from December 9 to 11, Eugene had himself discharged. On Christmas Eve, James entered his son in a private institution, Gaylord Farm, which proved distinctly more therapeutic: Eugene was discharged as an arrested case on the third of June, 1913; The Straw (1921), one of his most deeply felt early plays, is a heavily autobiographical depiction of his stay there.

Life’s Work

During his sanatorium stay, O’Neill crystallized his career goal: he would be a playwright. His most pervasive influence was the intense, self-tortured, somber Swedish writer, August Strindberg . In his acceptance speech for the Nobel Prize for Literature, awarded to him in 1936, O’Neill singled out Strindberg as “that greatest genius of all modern dramatists.... It was reading his plays ... that, above all else, first gave me the vision of what modern drama could be, and first inspired me with the urge to write for the theater myself.”

After his discharge from the institution, O’Neill boarded for a year with a private family and used this time to write thirteen plays, of which he included six one-act plays in a volume, Thirst (1914), subsidized by his father; he later disowned this collection, preventing its republication during his lifetime. From September, 1914, to May, 1915, he was a student in Professor George Pierce Baker’s playwriting class at Harvard, remembered by classmates as handsome, thin, shy, and restless.

In 1916, O’Neill fell in love with the high-spirited journalist Louise Bryant, already the mistress and soon to be the wife of the celebrated war correspondent John Reed (1887-1920). The two men liked each other, and the trio formed a turbulent triangle which persisted close to the day of O’Neill’s second marriage to Agnes Boulton on April 12, 1918. Indeed, Agnes reminded O’Neill of Louise: Both women were slender, pretty, and sophisticated; Agnes, however, was quiet and softly feminine, in contrast to Louise’s strident manner. The marriage to Agnes Boulton lasted eleven years; its first two years are vividly described in her account, Part of a Long Story (1958). The union resulted in two children. Shane O’Neill (1919-1975) was never able to settle on a career and became a hopeless heroin addict. Oona O’Neill (born 1925) married Charles Chaplin (1889-1977). O’Neill’s firstborn son, Eugene O’Neill, Jr., tall and handsome with a resonant voice, began a brilliant career as a classicist at Yale but turned increasingly alcoholic, resigned his academic post, and, in his fortieth year, committed suicide. O’Neill held himself apart from his children throughout his life, although he did make sporadic, intense, but always short-lived attempts to reach them intimately.

O’Neill’s first important play, The Emperor Jones, dramatizes, in eight scenes, Brutus Jones’s fall from “emperor” of a West Indian island to a primitive savage who is slaughtered by his rebellious people. Jones is a former Pullman porter who escapes imprisonment for murder, finds his way to the island, and there establishes himself as a despot by exploiting the natives’ fears and superstitions. While the play’s first and last scenes are realistic, the intervening six are expressionistic, consisting of Jones’s monologues and the visions of his fearful mind as he struggles through a tropical jungle. O’Neill manages to merge supernatural beliefs with psychological effects in a powerful union that shows his dramatic affinity with two noted German expressionists, Georg Kaiser (1878-1945) and Ernst Toller (1893-1939).

Desire Under the Elms (1924) is usually considered O’Neill’s finest play of the 1920’s, his first in the classic Greek mode. It is a modern treatment of the Phaedra-Hippolytus-Theseus myth, set on a New England farm in 1850. The father, seventy-five-year-old Ephraim Cabot (Theseus), returns to his farm with a passionate new wife, thirty-five-year-old Abbie (Phaedra), who falls in love with her twenty-five-year-old stepson, Eben (Hippolytus). Like Phaedra, Abbie confronts the young man in a...

(The entire section is 3118 words.)

Eugene O'Neill Eugene O’Neill (Critical Guide to Censorship and Literature)

Author Profile

For the first seven years of O’Neill’s life he traveled with his parents, while his father toured the country as the star in a stage version of The Count of Monte Cristo. He attended boarding schools before entering Princeton University in 1906. After failing to complete his freshman year, he spent the next six years working on steamships and living a drunken, derelict existence in various ports between voyages.

In 1912 O’Neill contracted tuberculosis. While recovering in a sanitarium he began to write plays, mostly only one act long, dealing with people and subject matter that had never been depicted on the American stage—derelicts, prostitutes, and drunken sailors....

(The entire section is 931 words.)

Eugene O'Neill Bibliography (Masterpieces of American Literature)

Bloom, Harold, ed. Eugene O’Neill. New York: Chelsea House, 1987. This collection includes essays by Lionel Trilling, Doris Falk, Arnold Goldman, Robert Lee, Travis Boyard, Thomas Van Laan, Jean Chathia, C. W. Bigsby, and Michael Manheim, arranged in chronological order by their original publication dates. The theoretical slant is thematic and philosophical, with detailed characters and plot analyses. Contains a brief bibliography.

Brietzke, Zander. The Aesthetics of Failure: Dynamic Structure in the Plays of Eugene O’Neill. Jefferson, N.C.: McFarland, 2001. A controversial but insightful study of O’Neill’s literary theory,...

(The entire section is 514 words.)