Because each story in this collection addresses familiar human emotion and experience with subtlety, precision, accuracy, and depth, the book does appeal to discerning adult readers. Nevertheless, the points of view, themes, and even prose styles in the collection are particularly well suited for the juvenile to young adult readership that Zolotow has in mind.
Seven of the ten stories are written in the first-person narrative style, which is particularly compelling for the juvenile reader because it more fully engages their empathy for the lead character. It may be no accident that the three stories written in third person—“Nina,” “The Visitor,” and “The Garden Party”—are the least viscerally affecting, the least accessible, to young readers. For example, in spite of the lovely, precise phrasing and visual imagery in Mansfield’s “The Garden Party,” its third-person narrative creates an ironic distance between what the main character, Laura, says that she feels and what the reader believes that she feels. It is a distance that an adult reader may enjoy more than a juvenile reader who longs to identify with the beautiful and charming teenage protagonist. The works that use the first-person narrative make their protagonists’ stories more immediate, more personal, and more painful. When Brodkey’s main character in “The State of Grace” suffers “the terrible desire to suddenly turn and run shouting back through the corridors of time, screaming at the boy I was, searching him out, and pounding on his chest: Love him, you damn fool, love him,” readers cannot help but feel his sorrow because they know and trust him—he is their friend and confidant, their narrator.
In one way or another, each of the collection’s stories...
(The entire section is 725 words.)